Evaluation of mechanical properties and morphology of miniscrews Ti6Al4V cold worked versus annealed in artificial bones

Abstract

Purpose

This study aimed to evaluate the influence of different manufacturing procedures (Eli annealed – hot work versus cold worked – cold work) of the raw material under mechanical properties and morphological characteristics of orthodontic miniscrews (MS).

Material and methods

Thirty MS were randomly separated into 3 types (n = 10) according to manufacturer and manufacturing process of the raw material: type A – SIN® annealed (control group); type B – Dentfix® annealed; and, type C – Dentfix® cold worked. MI were inserted in artificial bone blocks, through the manufacturer's specific manual key attached to the digital torquemeter stabilized via custom device. Data of fracture's occurrence was performed using Fisher's exact test. Comparisons between the other two types regarding insertion torque and removal torque were performed using the Mann-Whitney test. Data of fracture torque, shear stress, normal stress and torque ratio was submitted to Kruskal Wallis and Dunn tests (α = 0.05). Representative images of surface morphology and fractures were selected.

Results

Type C showed statistically the lowest fracture torque (N.cm) (26.11 ± 0.41) (P = 0.0012) and highest torque ratio (%) (98.74 ± 0.85) (P = 0.0007). Type C showed statistically higher calculated shear (MPa) (2,432.73 ± 508.41) and normal stress (MPa) (1,403.86 ± 293.39) than type B and type A, showing that they differed in relation to the mechanical strength of the material with which they were made (P = 0.0007).

Conclusion

Type A fractured completely inside the most apical bone. Type B and type C fractured closer to the transmucosal profile. Cold worked process should be more prone to fractures than those annealed raw manufactured.