Phosphorus limitation on CO2 fertilization effect in tropical forests informed by a coupled biogeochemical model

Abstract

Tropical forests store more than half of the world's terrestrial carbon (C) pool and account for one-third of global net primary productivity (NPP). Many terrestrial biosphere models (TBMs) estimate increased productivity in tropical forests throughout the 21st century due to CO₂ fertilization. However, phosphorus (P) limitations on vegetation photosynthesis and productivity could significantly reduce the CO₂ fertilization effect. Here, we used a carbon-nitrogen-phosphorus coupled model (Dynamic Land Ecosystem Model; DLEM-CNP) with heterogeneous maximum carboxylation rates to examine how P limitation has affected C fluxes in tropical forests during 1860–2018. Our model results showed that the inclusion of the P processes enhanced model performance in simulating ecosystem productivity. We further compared the simulations from DLEM-CNP, DLEM-CN, and DLEM-C and the results showed that the inclusion of P processes reduced the CO₂ fertilization effect on gross primary production (GPP) by 25% and 45%, and net ecosystem production (NEP) by 28% and 41%, respectively, relative to CN-only and C-only models. From the 1860s to the 2010s, the DLEM-CNP estimated that in tropical forests GPP increased by 17%, plant respiration (Ra) increased by 18%, ecosystem respiration (Rh) increased by 13%, NEP increased by 121% per unit area, respectively. Additionally, factorial experiments with DLEM-CNP showed that the enhanced NPP benefiting from the CO₂ fertilization effect had been offset by 135% due to deforestation from the 1860s to the 2010s. Our study highlights the importance of P limitation on the C cycle and the weakened CO₂ fertilization effect resulting from P limitation in tropical forests.