Refrigerant Selection in Air Conditioning Systems Considering Thermodynamic, Environmental, and Economic Performance Using the BHARAT-II Multi-Attribute Decision-Making Method

Abstract

A simple and effective multi-attribute decision-making method, named as "Best Holistic Adaptable Ranking of Attributes Technique (BHARAT)-II”, to choose the best refrigerant for air conditioning systems is presented. The thermodynamic properties of the refrigerants, and their environmental, and economic performances are also considered for the selection. Two case studies are provided to demonstrate the proposed multi-attribute decision-making method. The first case study addresses the problem of selecting the best refrigerant for residential split air conditioners out of 15 alternative refrigerants considering 12 selection attributes; the second case study addresses the problem of selecting the best refrigerant for automobile air conditioning systems by considering 14 alternative refrigerants and 13 selection attributes. The results of the proposed decision-making method are compared with those of other well-known multi-attribute decision-making methods such as EDAS, TOPSIS, and MOORA. The proposed method is shown to be simple to implement, providing a logical way for allocating weights to the selection attributes and is useful to solve the best alternative refrigerant selection problems of the residential as well as industrial refrigeration and air conditioning.