Comparison of diagnostic yields, operative times, and post-operative hemorrhage between twist drill versus burr hole craniotomy approaches for stereotactic needle brain biopsy.

Abstract

Stereotactic frameless needle brain biopsy is a common neurosurgical procedure performed via twist drill or open burr hole approaches. We aim to compare diagnostic yields and surgical outcomes to delineate the safety and efficacy of both approaches. A retrospective database of all stereotactic needle biopsy procedures performed at a single institution over 30 months was conglomerated. Demographics, medical comorbidities, operative details/complications, immediate post-operative imaging, and pathology were abstracted. Two hundred and twenty-five needle biopsies were identified, of which 165 (73.3%) were open, and 60 (26.7%) were twist drill. Diagnostic pathology yield rates between open (84.8%) and twist drill (93.3%) approaches were similar (p = 0.15), with a median of 4 cores taken in each (p = 0.30). Diagnostic tissue yields with an intra-operative pause for pathology confirmation was 90.4% compared to 79.1% without pause (p = 0.036, OR 2.49). Median operative times for open versus twist drill procedures were 68.0 min (IQR 49-83) versus 35.5 min (IQR 26-54), respectively (Wilcoxon p < 0.001), which remained significant after controlling for awaiting intraoperative pathology using bivariable linear modeling (p < 0.001). Intraoperative bleeding through the needle cannula was noted in 22 patients (9.8%), including eight twist drill (13.3%) and 14 open needles (8.5%). Of 197 cases (87.6%) with post-operative cranial imaging (CT/MRI), 90 (45.7%) demonstrated some degree of post-operative hemorrhage characterized as superficial (n = 10, 11.1%), deep/intralesional (n = 64, 71.1%) bleeding, or both (n = 16, 17.9%). Bleeding rates between open (46.7%) and twist drill (43.3%) approaches were similar (p = 0.78). Post-operative clinical decline or neurological change was noted in 9 patients (4.0%), including one twist drill (1.7%) and eight open needles (4.8%), among which 7 (78%) had deep blood products identified on post-operative imaging. Stereotactic needle biopsy via twist drill approach has similar diagnostic yield rates, asymptomatic bleeding rates, and post-operative complications with significantly shorter operative time and smaller incision size than conventional open burr hole needle biopsy. Using intra-operative frozen histopathology for presumed sufficient diagnostic tissue may improve final pathologic diagnostic rates regardless of approach technique.