Enhancing hydraulic efficiency in jet impingement sprinklers: Comparative analysis of aperture ratios compared with non-impingement sprinklers

Abstract

A jet impingement sprinkler was designed based on asymmetric collision between the primary and secondary jets to replace traditional rotating sprinklers that require additional water distribution devices to provide suitable water distribution at low pressures. The study focuses on the ratio of apertures between primary and secondary nozzles, deriving a theoretical relationship based on jet momentum. The factors contributing to the variation in hydraulic performance between jet-impingement and non-impinging sprinklers are elucidated by combining hydraulic performance experiments with experiments using high-speed photography (HSP). The results show that the developed jet impingement sprinkler achieved a smoother water distribution trend. The wetted radius and Christiansen's uniformity coefficient of the jet impingement sprinkler were evaluated using the Criteria Importance via the Intercriteria Correlation (CRITIC) method. A comparison of the average scores shows that an aperture ratio of 1.66 performs best under full pressure. By contrast, an aperture ratio of 1.33 exhibited superior performance at low pressure. Jet deflection angle and jet breakup length were obtained through HSP experiments. The relative error between the measured and theoretical jet deflection angles was less than 5%, demonstrating the reliability of the proposed theoretical calculation method. A non-linear curve was used to establish the relationship among the aperture ratio, diameter of the primary nozzle exit, jet breakup length, average measured jet deflection angle, working pressure, and wetted radius. The relative error between the calculated and measured values was within 4%, indicating the suitability of the new formula for calculating the wetted radius of jet impingement sprinklers.