Remote sensing of methane plumes: instrument tradeoff analysis for detecting and quantifying local sources at global scale

Abstract

Abstract. Methane (CH4) is the 2nd most important anthropogenic greenhouse gas with a significant impact on radiative forcing, tropospheric air quality and stratospheric water vapor. Remote-sensing observations enable the detection and quantification of local methane emissions across large geographical areas, which is a critical step for understanding local flux distributions and subsequently prioritizing mitigation strategies. Obtaining methane column concentration measurements with low noise and minimal surface interference has direct consequences for accurately determining the location and emission rates of methane sources. The quality of retrieved column enhancements depends on the choices of instrument and retrieval parameters. Here, we studied the changes in precision error and bias as a result of different spectral resolutions, instrument optical performance and detector exposure times by using a realistic instrument noise model. In addition, we formally analysed the impact of spectrally complex surface albedo features on retrievals using the Iterative Maximum a Posteriori- Differential Optical Absorption Spectroscopy (IMAP-DOAS) algorithm. We built an end-to-end modelling framework that can simulate observed radiances from reflected solar irradiance through a simulated CH4 plume over several natural and man-made surfaces. Our analysis shows that complex surface features can alias into retrieved methane abundances, explaining the existence of retrieval biases in current airborne methane observations. The impact can be mitigated with higher spectral resolution and a larger polynomial degree to approximate surface albedo variations. Using a spectral resolution of 1.5 nm, an exposure time of 20 ms, and a polynomial degree of 25, a retrieval precision error below 0.007 mole m−2 or 1.0 % of total atmospheric CH4 column can be achieved for high albedo cases, while minimizing the bias due to surface interference such that the noise is uncorrelated among various surfaces. At coarser spectral resolutions, it becomes increasingly harder to separate complex surface albedo features from atmospheric absorption features. Our modelling framework provides the basis for assessing trade-offs for future remote-sensing instruments and algorithmic designs. For instance, we find that improving the spectral resolution beyond 0.2 nm would actually decrease the retrieval precision as detector readout noise will play an increasing role. Our work contributes towards building an enhanced monitoring system that can measure CH4 concentration fields to determine methane sources accurately and efficiently at scale.