Marco Antonio Gonsales de Oliveira , Arnaldo José França Mazzei Nogueira
{"title":"Resistance and organized counter-resistance in conflict areas: an ethnography with Embraer's workers","authors":"Marco Antonio Gonsales de Oliveira , Arnaldo José França Mazzei Nogueira","doi":"10.1016/j.rausp.2016.06.018","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><p>The aim of this paper is to analyze the specificity of the conflict between capital and labor in the context of a global company like EMBRAER that has a strong influence in the region where it is located in Sao Jose dos Campos in São Paulo, Brazil. Since the resignation mass held by Embraer of more than four thousand workers in 2009 intensified labor conflicts, resistance movements of workers as strikes, labor mobilizations, labor, dissatisfactions and union complaints against the company that had adopted a flexible paradigm organization. Interestingly, these areas of conflict is explained in an unprecedented way a counter-resistance organized movement of employees whose culmination was a decision contrary to the continuation of a strike erupted in 2014. It was thought until then that the counteraction to union resistance movement of workers occurred only ideologically, personal or small groups despite being beneficiaries of the shares, never participate in such movements. This time participated, managers and technicians were organized against union resistance movement in defense of the values of the company to settle with the movement and unseat union leaders seeking to address labor dissatisfaction.</p><p>In the contemplation of this study was carried out an ethnographic approach to mold a study of extended case reasoned by the Public Sociology (see <span>Burawoy, 2005</span>). The ethnography option was due to its ability to identify how the contemporary global capitalism processes are mediated locally with various effects on the lives of workers, a difficult reality for the foundation of an opposition unions and the left in Brazil. The research process began in the Metalworkers Union of São José dos Campos and Region and approaches with the workers of Embraer were held for two years. The main conclusion of the article points out that there is a dialectic of conflict in contemporary capitalism than the same time promoting the workers’ resistance movements also reveals the effectiveness of consent policies of the typical business of post-Fordism, which in this case was manifested if as an unprecedented move against resistance-organized.</p></div>","PeriodicalId":30471,"journal":{"name":"RAUSP Revista de Administracao da Universidade de Sao Paulo","volume":"52 4","pages":"Pages 392-402"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2017-10-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://sci-hub-pdf.com/10.1016/j.rausp.2016.06.018","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"RAUSP Revista de Administracao da Universidade de Sao Paulo","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0080210717301814","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The aim of this paper is to analyze the specificity of the conflict between capital and labor in the context of a global company like EMBRAER that has a strong influence in the region where it is located in Sao Jose dos Campos in São Paulo, Brazil. Since the resignation mass held by Embraer of more than four thousand workers in 2009 intensified labor conflicts, resistance movements of workers as strikes, labor mobilizations, labor, dissatisfactions and union complaints against the company that had adopted a flexible paradigm organization. Interestingly, these areas of conflict is explained in an unprecedented way a counter-resistance organized movement of employees whose culmination was a decision contrary to the continuation of a strike erupted in 2014. It was thought until then that the counteraction to union resistance movement of workers occurred only ideologically, personal or small groups despite being beneficiaries of the shares, never participate in such movements. This time participated, managers and technicians were organized against union resistance movement in defense of the values of the company to settle with the movement and unseat union leaders seeking to address labor dissatisfaction.
In the contemplation of this study was carried out an ethnographic approach to mold a study of extended case reasoned by the Public Sociology (see Burawoy, 2005). The ethnography option was due to its ability to identify how the contemporary global capitalism processes are mediated locally with various effects on the lives of workers, a difficult reality for the foundation of an opposition unions and the left in Brazil. The research process began in the Metalworkers Union of São José dos Campos and Region and approaches with the workers of Embraer were held for two years. The main conclusion of the article points out that there is a dialectic of conflict in contemporary capitalism than the same time promoting the workers’ resistance movements also reveals the effectiveness of consent policies of the typical business of post-Fordism, which in this case was manifested if as an unprecedented move against resistance-organized.
本文的目的是分析在像巴西航空工业公司这样的全球性公司的背景下,资本和劳动力之间的冲突的特殊性,在该地区有很强的影响力,它位于巴西圣保罗的圣若塞多斯坎波斯。自2009年巴西航空工业公司4000多名工人集体辞职以来,对采用灵活范式组织的公司的劳资冲突、罢工、工人动员、劳动、不满和工会投诉等工人抵抗运动加剧。有趣的是,这些冲突地区以一种前所未有的方式解释了一场有组织的员工反抵抗运动,其高潮是与2014年爆发的罢工的继续相反的决定。在此之前,人们一直认为,对工人工会抵抗运动的对抗只发生在思想上,个人或小团体虽然是股份的受益者,但从不参与这种运动。这次参与的经理和技术人员组织了反对工会抵抗运动,以捍卫公司的价值观,与运动达成和解,并推翻了寻求解决劳工不满的工会领导人。在这项研究的思考中,进行了一种民族志方法来塑造公共社会学推理的扩展案例研究(见Burawoy, 2005)。民族志的选择是由于它能够确定当代全球资本主义进程如何在当地调解,并对工人的生活产生各种影响,这对巴西反对派工会和左翼的基础来说是一个困难的现实。研究过程始于s o jossdos Campos和地区的金属工人工会,并与巴西航空工业公司的工人进行了两年的接触。文章的主要结论指出,当代资本主义存在着一种矛盾的辩证法,与此同时,推动工人抵抗运动也揭示了后福特主义典型企业的同意政策的有效性,在这种情况下,同意政策表现为一种前所未有的反对抵抗组织的行动。