Refusal of implantable cardioverter defibrillator generator replacement: the nurse's role.

Abstract

An adult patient who is conscious and mentally competent has the right to refuse any medical or surgical procedure even when the best medical opinion deems it necessary for life. The doctrine of informed consent is grounded on the premise that a physician's judgment is subservient to the patient's right to self-determination. Some suggestions for the future are offered. It may be beneficial to have a formal doctrine of informed refusal incorporated into the existing system of informed consent thus having patients sign a refusal of treatment form just as they sign a form consenting to treatment. Even if the physician and patient share an ideal relationship that includes mutual respect and participation in decision making, the consent to treatment or refusal of treatment should be documented both on a form and in the physician's own words in the patient record to avoid any discrepancies that may arise later. Items that may eventually be added to the list of requirements for informed consent or refusal include the impact of the treatment or procedure on the patient's job or family situation, impact on quality of life, and the potential long-term cost to the patient or to public or private health care payers.