Comparison of Parallel Genetic Algorithm and Particle Swarm Optimization for Parameter Calibration in Hydrological Simulation

Abstract

Parameter calibration is an important part of hydrological simulation and affects the final simulation results. In this paper, we introduce heuristic optimization algorithms, genetic algorithm (GA) to cope with the complexity of the parameter calibration problem, and use particle swarm optimization algorithm (PSO) as a comparison. For large scale hydrological simulations, we use a multilevel parallel parameter calibration framework to make full use of processor resources, accelerate the process of solving high-dimensional parameter calibration. Further, we test and apply the experiments on domestic supercomputers. The results of parameter calibration with GA and PSO can basically reach the ideal value of 0.65 and above, with PSO achieving a speedup of 58.52 on TianHe-2 supercomputer. The experimental results indicate that by using a parallel implementation on multicore CPUs, high-dimensional parameter calibration in large scale hydrological simulation is possible. Moreover, our comparison of the two algorithms shows that the GA obtains better calibration results, and the PSO has a more pronounced acceleration effect.