{"title":"Behind my pet's shadow: exploring the motives underlying the tendency of socially excluded consumers to anthropomorphize their pets","authors":"Elif Tanrikulu, Ibrahim Taylan Dortyol","doi":"10.1108/qrj-05-2023-0070","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Purpose Social exclusion is a complicated psychological phenomenon with behavioral ramifications that influences consumers' lifestyles and behaviors. In contrast, anthropomorphism is a phenomenon that marketing strategists employ and that occurs in customers' lives as a result of social isolation. The literature discusses these two complicated structures as ones that require investigation based on consumer judgments. The purpose of the current study is to understand the fundamental motivations that underlie the propensity for anthropomorphizing in people who suffer social isolation through their pets. Design/methodology/approach To look into the motivations driving these themes, a study technique with three distinct components was created. Cyberball was employed as a technique to manipulate social exclusion in the initial stage of this research methodology. Two scenarios, one of which had an anthropomorphizing tendency and the other of which did not, were presented to participants who had suffered social exclusion and advanced to the second phase in order to determine the anthropomorphizing tendency. The Attachment to Pets Scale (LAPS), which Johnson et al . (1992) created based on the social support provided by pets, was utilized while creating the scenarios. The Zaltman method was applied as an interviewing technique in the third stage of the research design, with the interviewees being guided by visuals that reflected their emotions and thoughts. Findings The results of the data analysis were evaluated in light of social psychology. A more thorough expression of the complex relationship between anthropomorphism and those who experience social exclusion has been made. The findings showed that when people anthropomorphize their pets in response to feelings of social exclusion, the motivations that emerge include pure love, loyalty, animals' need for a human, living creature and embracing. The study emphasizes that these ideas will be helpful in customers' interactions with anthropomorphic objects. Practical implications As a contribution to the literature, the study findings offer the five major motivations underpinning these beliefs. These findings may help marketing scientists comprehend social exclusion and anthropomorphism, thereby benefiting the individual and society. Originality/value The majority of research in the literature (Chen et al. , 2017; Epley et al. , 2008; Eyssel and Reich, 2013; Waytz et al. , 2019) verified that people who were socially excluded would use anthropomorphism, but no studies were discovered about the motivations outlined in the current study. The results of this investigation should add to the body of knowledge in this area. The pet was employed as an anthropomorphism tool in the current study because it is the object that a person chooses to anthropomorphize deliberately and independently. It adds to the study's originality by explaining in the individual's own terminology how he will feel as a result of his social isolation, how he will make up for it and potential responses he may have. In addition to all of these contributions, the study's primary goal of analyzing the motivations behind anthropomorphism yields significant findings that are relevant to both industry and academic research.","PeriodicalId":47040,"journal":{"name":"Qualitative Research Journal","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.8000,"publicationDate":"2023-11-06","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Qualitative Research Journal","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1108/qrj-05-2023-0070","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"SOCIAL SCIENCES, INTERDISCIPLINARY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Purpose Social exclusion is a complicated psychological phenomenon with behavioral ramifications that influences consumers' lifestyles and behaviors. In contrast, anthropomorphism is a phenomenon that marketing strategists employ and that occurs in customers' lives as a result of social isolation. The literature discusses these two complicated structures as ones that require investigation based on consumer judgments. The purpose of the current study is to understand the fundamental motivations that underlie the propensity for anthropomorphizing in people who suffer social isolation through their pets. Design/methodology/approach To look into the motivations driving these themes, a study technique with three distinct components was created. Cyberball was employed as a technique to manipulate social exclusion in the initial stage of this research methodology. Two scenarios, one of which had an anthropomorphizing tendency and the other of which did not, were presented to participants who had suffered social exclusion and advanced to the second phase in order to determine the anthropomorphizing tendency. The Attachment to Pets Scale (LAPS), which Johnson et al . (1992) created based on the social support provided by pets, was utilized while creating the scenarios. The Zaltman method was applied as an interviewing technique in the third stage of the research design, with the interviewees being guided by visuals that reflected their emotions and thoughts. Findings The results of the data analysis were evaluated in light of social psychology. A more thorough expression of the complex relationship between anthropomorphism and those who experience social exclusion has been made. The findings showed that when people anthropomorphize their pets in response to feelings of social exclusion, the motivations that emerge include pure love, loyalty, animals' need for a human, living creature and embracing. The study emphasizes that these ideas will be helpful in customers' interactions with anthropomorphic objects. Practical implications As a contribution to the literature, the study findings offer the five major motivations underpinning these beliefs. These findings may help marketing scientists comprehend social exclusion and anthropomorphism, thereby benefiting the individual and society. Originality/value The majority of research in the literature (Chen et al. , 2017; Epley et al. , 2008; Eyssel and Reich, 2013; Waytz et al. , 2019) verified that people who were socially excluded would use anthropomorphism, but no studies were discovered about the motivations outlined in the current study. The results of this investigation should add to the body of knowledge in this area. The pet was employed as an anthropomorphism tool in the current study because it is the object that a person chooses to anthropomorphize deliberately and independently. It adds to the study's originality by explaining in the individual's own terminology how he will feel as a result of his social isolation, how he will make up for it and potential responses he may have. In addition to all of these contributions, the study's primary goal of analyzing the motivations behind anthropomorphism yields significant findings that are relevant to both industry and academic research.
社会排斥是一种复杂的心理现象,它会影响消费者的生活方式和行为。相比之下,拟人化是营销战略家所采用的一种现象,这种现象由于社会孤立而发生在客户的生活中。文献讨论了这两个复杂的结构,需要根据消费者的判断进行调查。当前研究的目的是了解那些因宠物而遭受社会孤立的人倾向拟人化的根本动机。设计/方法/方法为了研究驱动这些主题的动机,我们创建了一个包含三个不同组成部分的学习技巧。在这一研究方法的初始阶段,Cyberball被用作操纵社会排斥的技术。为了确定拟人化倾向,向遭受社会排斥并进入第二阶段的参与者展示了两种场景,其中一种有拟人化倾向,另一种没有拟人化倾向。宠物依恋量表(LAPS), Johnson等人。(1992)基于宠物提供的社会支持而创建,在创建场景时使用。在研究设计的第三阶段,采用了Zaltman方法作为访谈技术,受访者被反映他们的情绪和思想的视觉效果所引导。结果从社会心理学角度对数据分析结果进行了评价。拟人论和那些经历社会排斥的人之间的复杂关系已经得到了更彻底的表达。研究结果表明,当人们出于社会排斥感而将宠物拟人化时,出现的动机包括纯粹的爱、忠诚、动物对人类、生物和拥抱的需求。该研究强调,这些想法将有助于客户与拟人化物体的互动。作为对文献的贡献,研究结果提供了支撑这些信念的五个主要动机。这些发现可能有助于营销科学家理解社会排斥和拟人化,从而有利于个人和社会。原创性/价值文献中的大多数研究(Chen et al., 2017;Epley et al., 2008;Eyssel and Reich, 2013;Waytz等人,2019)证实,被社会排斥的人会使用拟人化,但没有发现关于本研究中概述的动机的研究。这项调查的结果应该会增加这一领域的知识体系。在本研究中,宠物被用作拟人化工具,因为它是一个人有意识地、独立地选择拟人化的对象。它通过用个人自己的术语解释他对社会孤立的感受、他将如何弥补以及他可能有的潜在反应,增加了这项研究的独创性。除了所有这些贡献之外,该研究的主要目标是分析拟人化背后的动机,产生与行业和学术研究相关的重要发现。
期刊介绍:
Qualitative Research Journal (QRJ) is an international journal devoted to the communication of the theory and practice of qualitative research in the human sciences. It is interdisciplinary and eclectic, covering all methodologies that can be described as qualitative. It offers an international forum for researchers and practitioners to advance knowledge and promote good qualitative research practices. QRJ deals comprehensively with the collection, analysis and presentation of qualitative data in the human sciences as well as theoretical and conceptual inquiry.