Africa between East and West: Searching for its own path. Book review of ‘La Russie face aux occidentaux en Afrique centrale: Pour un arrimage des Africains aux enjeux de puissance post-bipolarité’ by F.X.N. Edzimbi
{"title":"Africa between East and West: Searching for its own path. Book review of ‘La Russie face aux occidentaux en Afrique centrale: Pour un arrimage des Africains aux enjeux de puissance post-bipolarité’ by F.X.N. Edzimbi","authors":"A. V. Nefedov","doi":"10.48015/2076-7404-2023-15-2-184-200","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The book under review is a new research by Cameroonian scholar Francois Xavier Noah Edzimbi ‘Russia and the West in Central Africa: How African countries can adapt to the challenges of the post-bipolar era’ (‘La Russie face aux Occidentaux en Afrique centrale: Pour un arrimage des Africains aux enjeux de puissance post-bipolarite’), published in France in 2022. The reviewer emphasizes that in the context of a new exacerbation of great power rivalry on the African continent this research is particularly relevant since it shows how the situation is perceived directly in Africa, which in turn can help Russia better understand the worldviews of Central African partners and develop a more balanced policy in the region. The book under review synthesizes the elements of realist and constructivist approaches in order to provide a comprehensive view of interactions between African states and extra-regional powers, their respective interests and values. The research focuses on the reasons for Russia’s growing presence in Central Africa. It is in this context, and in order to illuminate the specifics of Russia’s foreign policy in the region that the author addresses the approaches of other actors (namely, the United States and France) towards the relations with African states in the post-bipolar era. According to N. Edzimbi, Russian foreign policy in Central Africa is rather ambiguous: on the one hand, Russia counterbalances the influence of the United States and France, but, on the other hand, it pursues its own pragmatic goals and in this sense differs little from other leading powers. The author argues that despite seemingly friendly rhetoric, all global actors regard Central Africa as yet another arena of interstate rivalry, and suggests that the African countries should develop an independent foreign policy strategy, including, among other things, a force component. At the same time, the Cameroonian researcher emphasizes that this issue can be addressed if African states overcome the ‘learned helplessness syndrome’ and abandon the subordinate role in favor of developing their own power policy. The reviewer concludes that this work may be of interest to a wide range of readers, but it will be especially useful for specialists in African studies and international relations experts who specialize on the challenges faced by Africa and on the Russian-African relations.","PeriodicalId":31668,"journal":{"name":"Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta Seria 18 Sociologia i Politologia","volume":"159 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2023-09-21","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta Seria 18 Sociologia i Politologia","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.48015/2076-7404-2023-15-2-184-200","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The book under review is a new research by Cameroonian scholar Francois Xavier Noah Edzimbi ‘Russia and the West in Central Africa: How African countries can adapt to the challenges of the post-bipolar era’ (‘La Russie face aux Occidentaux en Afrique centrale: Pour un arrimage des Africains aux enjeux de puissance post-bipolarite’), published in France in 2022. The reviewer emphasizes that in the context of a new exacerbation of great power rivalry on the African continent this research is particularly relevant since it shows how the situation is perceived directly in Africa, which in turn can help Russia better understand the worldviews of Central African partners and develop a more balanced policy in the region. The book under review synthesizes the elements of realist and constructivist approaches in order to provide a comprehensive view of interactions between African states and extra-regional powers, their respective interests and values. The research focuses on the reasons for Russia’s growing presence in Central Africa. It is in this context, and in order to illuminate the specifics of Russia’s foreign policy in the region that the author addresses the approaches of other actors (namely, the United States and France) towards the relations with African states in the post-bipolar era. According to N. Edzimbi, Russian foreign policy in Central Africa is rather ambiguous: on the one hand, Russia counterbalances the influence of the United States and France, but, on the other hand, it pursues its own pragmatic goals and in this sense differs little from other leading powers. The author argues that despite seemingly friendly rhetoric, all global actors regard Central Africa as yet another arena of interstate rivalry, and suggests that the African countries should develop an independent foreign policy strategy, including, among other things, a force component. At the same time, the Cameroonian researcher emphasizes that this issue can be addressed if African states overcome the ‘learned helplessness syndrome’ and abandon the subordinate role in favor of developing their own power policy. The reviewer concludes that this work may be of interest to a wide range of readers, but it will be especially useful for specialists in African studies and international relations experts who specialize on the challenges faced by Africa and on the Russian-African relations.
正在审查的这本书是喀麦隆学者弗朗索瓦·泽维尔·诺亚·埃德津比(Francois Xavier Noah Edzimbi)的一项新研究,题为“俄罗斯和中非的西方:非洲国家如何适应后两极时代的挑战”(“La Russie face aux Occidentaux en Afrique centrale: Pour un arrimage des Africains aux enjeux de puissance后两极”),于2022年在法国出版。审稿人强调,在非洲大陆大国竞争加剧的背景下,这项研究特别相关,因为它显示了非洲如何直接感知局势,这反过来可以帮助俄罗斯更好地了解中非伙伴的世界观,并在该地区制定更平衡的政策。本书综合了现实主义和建构主义方法的要素,以提供非洲国家与地区外大国、各自利益和价值观之间相互作用的全面观点。这项研究的重点是俄罗斯在中非日益增长的存在的原因。正是在这种背景下,为了阐明俄罗斯在该地区外交政策的具体情况,作者探讨了其他行为体(即美国和法国)在后两极时代处理与非洲国家关系的方法。在N. Edzimbi看来,俄罗斯在中非的外交政策相当模糊:一方面,俄罗斯制衡美国和法国的影响力,但另一方面,俄罗斯追求自己的务实目标,在这个意义上与其他主要大国差别不大。作者认为,尽管表面上是友好的言辞,但所有全球行动者都认为中非是另一个国家间竞争的舞台,并建议非洲国家应制定独立的外交政策战略,除其他外,包括武力组成部分。同时,这位喀麦隆的研究者强调,如果非洲国家克服“习得性无助综合症”,放弃从属角色,转而发展自己的权力政策,这个问题是可以解决的。审稿人的结论是,这本书可能会引起广大读者的兴趣,但它对非洲研究专家和国际关系专家特别有用,他们专门研究非洲面临的挑战和俄非关系。