Fatemeh Saba, Hooman Latifi, Mohammad Javad Valadan Zoej, Rohollah Esmaili
{"title":"Mapping dead understorey Buxus hyrcana Pojark using Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-1 data","authors":"Fatemeh Saba, Hooman Latifi, Mohammad Javad Valadan Zoej, Rohollah Esmaili","doi":"10.1093/forestry/cpac049","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The Hyrcanian Forests comprise a continuous 800-km belt of mostly deciduous broadleaf forests and are considered as Iran’s most important vegetation region in terms of density, canopy cover and species diversity. One of the few evergreen species of the Hyrcanian Forests is the box tree (Buxus), which is seriously threatened by box blight disease and box tree moth outbreaks. Therefore, information on the spatial distribution of intact and infested box trees is essential for recovery monitoring, control treatment and management. To address this critical knowledge gap, we integrated a genetic algorithm (GA) with a support vector machine (SVM) ensemble classification based on the combination of leaf-off optical Sentinel-2 and radar Sentinel-1 data to map the spatial distribution of box tree mortality. We additionally considered the overstorey species composition to account for a potential impact of overstory stand composition on the spectral signature of understorey defoliation. We consequently defined target classes based on the combination of dominant overstorey trees (using two measures including the relative frequency and the diameter at breast height) and two defoliation levels of box trees (including dead and healthy box trees). Our classification workflow applied a GA to simultaneously derive optimal vegetation indices (VIs) and tuning parameters of the SVM. Then the distribution of box tree defoliation was mapped by an SVM ensemble with bagging using GA-optimized VIs and radar data. The GA results revealed that normalized difference vegetation index, red edge normalized difference vegetation index and green normalized difference vegetation index were appropriate for box tree defoliation mapping. An additional comparison of GA-SVM (using GA-optimized VIs and tuning parameters) with a simple SVM (using all VIs and user-based tuning parameters) showed that our suggested workflow performs notably better than the simple SVM (overall accuracy of 0.79 vs 0.74). Incorporating Sentinel-1 data to GA-SVM, marginally improved the performance of the model (overall accuracy: 0.80). The SVM ensemble model using Sentinel-2 and -1 data yielded high accuracies and low uncertainties in mapping of box tree defoliation. The results showed that infested box trees were mostly located at low elevations, low slope and facing north. We conclude that mortality of evergreen understorey tree species can be mapped with good accuracies using freely available satellite data if a suitable work-flow is applied.","PeriodicalId":12342,"journal":{"name":"Forestry","volume":"18 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":3.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-12-09","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Forestry","FirstCategoryId":"97","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1093/forestry/cpac049","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"农林科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"FORESTRY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The Hyrcanian Forests comprise a continuous 800-km belt of mostly deciduous broadleaf forests and are considered as Iran’s most important vegetation region in terms of density, canopy cover and species diversity. One of the few evergreen species of the Hyrcanian Forests is the box tree (Buxus), which is seriously threatened by box blight disease and box tree moth outbreaks. Therefore, information on the spatial distribution of intact and infested box trees is essential for recovery monitoring, control treatment and management. To address this critical knowledge gap, we integrated a genetic algorithm (GA) with a support vector machine (SVM) ensemble classification based on the combination of leaf-off optical Sentinel-2 and radar Sentinel-1 data to map the spatial distribution of box tree mortality. We additionally considered the overstorey species composition to account for a potential impact of overstory stand composition on the spectral signature of understorey defoliation. We consequently defined target classes based on the combination of dominant overstorey trees (using two measures including the relative frequency and the diameter at breast height) and two defoliation levels of box trees (including dead and healthy box trees). Our classification workflow applied a GA to simultaneously derive optimal vegetation indices (VIs) and tuning parameters of the SVM. Then the distribution of box tree defoliation was mapped by an SVM ensemble with bagging using GA-optimized VIs and radar data. The GA results revealed that normalized difference vegetation index, red edge normalized difference vegetation index and green normalized difference vegetation index were appropriate for box tree defoliation mapping. An additional comparison of GA-SVM (using GA-optimized VIs and tuning parameters) with a simple SVM (using all VIs and user-based tuning parameters) showed that our suggested workflow performs notably better than the simple SVM (overall accuracy of 0.79 vs 0.74). Incorporating Sentinel-1 data to GA-SVM, marginally improved the performance of the model (overall accuracy: 0.80). The SVM ensemble model using Sentinel-2 and -1 data yielded high accuracies and low uncertainties in mapping of box tree defoliation. The results showed that infested box trees were mostly located at low elevations, low slope and facing north. We conclude that mortality of evergreen understorey tree species can be mapped with good accuracies using freely available satellite data if a suitable work-flow is applied.
海卡尼亚森林包括一个连续800公里的落叶阔叶林带,在密度、冠层覆盖和物种多样性方面被认为是伊朗最重要的植被区。白杨(Buxus)是海canian森林中为数不多的常绿树种之一,它受到白杨病和白杨蛾的严重威胁。因此,完整和侵染箱形树的空间分布信息对恢复监测、防治和管理具有重要意义。为了解决这一关键的知识差距,我们将遗传算法(GA)与支持向量机(SVM)集成分类相结合,基于叶片光学Sentinel-2和雷达Sentinel-1数据来绘制箱树死亡率的空间分布。我们还考虑了林分组成对林下落叶光谱特征的潜在影响。因此,我们根据优势上层树木(使用两种测量方法,包括相对频率和胸高直径)和两种落叶水平(包括死亡和健康的箱子树)的组合来定义目标类别。我们的分类工作流程采用遗传算法同时获得最优植被指数(VIs)和支持向量机的调优参数。在此基础上,利用ga优化后的可视化数据和雷达数据,利用支持向量机集合和套袋映射箱形树的落叶分布。遗传分析结果表明,归一化植被差异指数、红边归一化植被差异指数和绿色归一化植被差异指数适合于箱形树落叶制图。GA-SVM(使用ga优化的VIs和调优参数)与简单的SVM(使用所有VIs和基于用户的调优参数)的额外比较表明,我们建议的工作流表现明显优于简单的SVM(总体精度为0.79 vs 0.74)。将Sentinel-1数据与GA-SVM结合,略微提高了模型的性能(总体精度:0.80)。基于Sentinel-2和sentinel -1数据的SVM集成模型在箱形树落叶制图中具有较高的精度和较低的不确定性。结果表明,受侵染的箱子树多分布在低海拔、低坡度、朝北的位置。我们的结论是,如果采用合适的工作流程,可以使用免费的卫星数据绘制常绿林下树种的死亡率,并具有较高的精度。
期刊介绍:
The journal is inclusive of all subjects, geographical zones and study locations, including trees in urban environments, plantations and natural forests. We welcome papers that consider economic, environmental and social factors and, in particular, studies that take an integrated approach to sustainable management. In considering suitability for publication, attention is given to the originality of contributions and their likely impact on policy and practice, as well as their contribution to the development of knowledge.
Special Issues - each year one edition of Forestry will be a Special Issue and will focus on one subject in detail; this will usually be by publication of the proceedings of an international meeting.