{"title":"Performance evaluation of surrogate models for simulating multiphase NAPL transport in heterogeneous aquifers","authors":"Litang Hu, Menglin Zhang, Lei Tian, Shiqi Huang","doi":"10.2166/nh.2023.209","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><div data- reveal-group-><div><img alt=\"graphic\" data-src=\"https://iwa.silverchair-cdn.com/iwa/content_public/journal/hr/54/12/10.2166_nh.2023.209/1/m_hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.png?Expires=1706783784&Signature=xYuqz8BB5GGlvRIdVHPF8v18al8eqWfAaFL8gYEduSUfYv0~RrA-qbz9nHuoDLdsIswnjWr1anW2Hr~oj75wDXMLfa537uV0jGK-E~e6DzK2cjd6u6FlPbf~RjD0-8Hgx2hK1r9PWvsKFMTMvqueDtydBbof0BGcCgmxTWO3s3dr~l9eHPJRVTJLQ9LfGsb7YC9qp7OLd1-DygtjiCqBAgH0Z55TslyHa9iZq-yoPWpQIoa5e4uYi~ov1TDIJ8VRR925lZGGhFOmj-rUh6jDirrBbjyl7pPP3I4FaFP0WKkzC6KkE0uLPFI9nBWlZYFtHG4F4mPZpLJAih3DvDhx0A__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIE5G5CRDK6RD3PGA\" path-from-xml=\"hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.tif\" src=\"https://iwa.silverchair-cdn.com/iwa/content_public/journal/hr/54/12/10.2166_nh.2023.209/1/m_hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.png?Expires=1706783784&Signature=xYuqz8BB5GGlvRIdVHPF8v18al8eqWfAaFL8gYEduSUfYv0~RrA-qbz9nHuoDLdsIswnjWr1anW2Hr~oj75wDXMLfa537uV0jGK-E~e6DzK2cjd6u6FlPbf~RjD0-8Hgx2hK1r9PWvsKFMTMvqueDtydBbof0BGcCgmxTWO3s3dr~l9eHPJRVTJLQ9LfGsb7YC9qp7OLd1-DygtjiCqBAgH0Z55TslyHa9iZq-yoPWpQIoa5e4uYi~ov1TDIJ8VRR925lZGGhFOmj-rUh6jDirrBbjyl7pPP3I4FaFP0WKkzC6KkE0uLPFI9nBWlZYFtHG4F4mPZpLJAih3DvDhx0A__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIE5G5CRDK6RD3PGA\"/><div>View largeDownload slide</div></div></div><div content- data-reveal=\"data-reveal\"><div><img alt=\"graphic\" data-src=\"https://iwa.silverchair-cdn.com/iwa/content_public/journal/hr/54/12/10.2166_nh.2023.209/1/m_hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.png?Expires=1706783784&Signature=xYuqz8BB5GGlvRIdVHPF8v18al8eqWfAaFL8gYEduSUfYv0~RrA-qbz9nHuoDLdsIswnjWr1anW2Hr~oj75wDXMLfa537uV0jGK-E~e6DzK2cjd6u6FlPbf~RjD0-8Hgx2hK1r9PWvsKFMTMvqueDtydBbof0BGcCgmxTWO3s3dr~l9eHPJRVTJLQ9LfGsb7YC9qp7OLd1-DygtjiCqBAgH0Z55TslyHa9iZq-yoPWpQIoa5e4uYi~ov1TDIJ8VRR925lZGGhFOmj-rUh6jDirrBbjyl7pPP3I4FaFP0WKkzC6KkE0uLPFI9nBWlZYFtHG4F4mPZpLJAih3DvDhx0A__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIE5G5CRDK6RD3PGA\" path-from-xml=\"hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.tif\" src=\"https://iwa.silverchair-cdn.com/iwa/content_public/journal/hr/54/12/10.2166_nh.2023.209/1/m_hydrology-d-23-00109gf01.png?Expires=1706783784&Signature=xYuqz8BB5GGlvRIdVHPF8v18al8eqWfAaFL8gYEduSUfYv0~RrA-qbz9nHuoDLdsIswnjWr1anW2Hr~oj75wDXMLfa537uV0jGK-E~e6DzK2cjd6u6FlPbf~RjD0-8Hgx2hK1r9PWvsKFMTMvqueDtydBbof0BGcCgmxTWO3s3dr~l9eHPJRVTJLQ9LfGsb7YC9qp7OLd1-DygtjiCqBAgH0Z55TslyHa9iZq-yoPWpQIoa5e4uYi~ov1TDIJ8VRR925lZGGhFOmj-rUh6jDirrBbjyl7pPP3I4FaFP0WKkzC6KkE0uLPFI9nBWlZYFtHG4F4mPZpLJAih3DvDhx0A__&Key-Pair-Id=APKAIE5G5CRDK6RD3PGA\"/><div>View largeDownload slide</div></div><i> </i><span>Close modal</span></div></div><p>A better understanding of the distribution of nonaqueous phase liquid (NAPL) plumes is of great importance to groundwater pollution remediation and control. However, the efficiency of surrogate models in simulating the transport is still not well addressed. Selecting a leakage problem as an example, 50 sets of random permeability distributions are generated using the Monte Carlo method, and a numerical model is used to obtain benchmark data of NAPL transport. Four machine learning methods are employed to simulate dense NAPL transport under point leakage sources across spatiotemporal scales. The validation of the models demonstrate that the random forest model can also effectively capture the spatial-temporal distribution of the plume in heterogeneous aquifers, with a maximum mean absolute error and root mean square error smaller than 5.55 × 10<sup>−4</sup> and 5.88 × 10<sup>−5</sup>, respectively. Meanwhile, the multiple phase outcome from the random forest model fits well with the numerical results under the scenarios of linear leakage sources and light NAPL transport. The total time consumed in the computation is reduced by over 150 times after using the surrogate models. The results suggest that surrogate models can provide a promising way to understand NAPL transport in heterogeneous aquifers.</p>","PeriodicalId":13096,"journal":{"name":"Hydrology Research","volume":"3 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":2.6000,"publicationDate":"2023-12-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Hydrology Research","FirstCategoryId":"93","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2166/nh.2023.209","RegionNum":4,"RegionCategory":"环境科学与生态学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"WATER RESOURCES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
View largeDownload slide
View largeDownload slide
Close modal
A better understanding of the distribution of nonaqueous phase liquid (NAPL) plumes is of great importance to groundwater pollution remediation and control. However, the efficiency of surrogate models in simulating the transport is still not well addressed. Selecting a leakage problem as an example, 50 sets of random permeability distributions are generated using the Monte Carlo method, and a numerical model is used to obtain benchmark data of NAPL transport. Four machine learning methods are employed to simulate dense NAPL transport under point leakage sources across spatiotemporal scales. The validation of the models demonstrate that the random forest model can also effectively capture the spatial-temporal distribution of the plume in heterogeneous aquifers, with a maximum mean absolute error and root mean square error smaller than 5.55 × 10−4 and 5.88 × 10−5, respectively. Meanwhile, the multiple phase outcome from the random forest model fits well with the numerical results under the scenarios of linear leakage sources and light NAPL transport. The total time consumed in the computation is reduced by over 150 times after using the surrogate models. The results suggest that surrogate models can provide a promising way to understand NAPL transport in heterogeneous aquifers.
期刊介绍:
Hydrology Research provides international coverage on all aspects of hydrology in its widest sense, and welcomes the submission of papers from across the subject. While emphasis is placed on studies of the hydrological cycle, the Journal also covers the physics and chemistry of water. Hydrology Research is intended to be a link between basic hydrological research and the practical application of scientific results within the broad field of water management.