Combination MCP-Mod for two-drug combination dose-ranging studies.

Abstract

Combination therapies with multiple mechanisms of action can offer improved efficacy and/or safety profiles when compared to a single therapy with one mechanism of action. Consequently, the number of combination therapy studies have increased multi-fold, both in oncology and non-oncology indications. However, identifying the optimal doses of each drug in a combination therapy can require a large sample size and prolong study timelines, especially when full factorial designs are used. In this paper, we extend the MCP-Mod design of Bretz, Pinheiro, and Branson to a three-dimensional space to model the dose-response surface of a two-drug combination under the framework of Combination (Comb) MCP-Mod. The resulting model yields a set of dosages for each drug in the combination that elicits the target response so that an optimal dose for the combination can be selected for pivotal studies. We construct three-dimensional dose-response models for the combination and formulate the contrast test statistic to select the best model, which can then be used to select the optimal dose. Guidance to calculate power and sample size calculations are provided to assist study design. Simulation studies show that Comb MCP-Mod performs as well as the conventional multiple comparisons approach in controlling the family-wise error rate at the desired alpha level. However, Comb MCP-Mod is more powerful than the classical multiple comparisons approach in detecting dose-response relationships when treatment is non-null. The probability of correctly identifying the underlying dose-response relationship is generally higher when using Comb MCP-Mod than when using the multiple comparisons approach.