Effect of chronic heavy tobacco smoking on ankle fracture healing

Abstract

Introduction

Tobacco smoking is linked to an elevated risk of osteomyelitis and delayed healing in long bone fractures. However, the impact of smoking on bone union and soft tissue recovery following ankle fractures remains unclear. This study presents a retrospective comparative analysis evaluating the effects of chronic heavy tobacco smoking on the healing process and outcomes of ankle fractures after surgical interventions.

Materials and Methods

We examined 220 consecutive cases of chronic heavy smokers (CHS) with closed ankle fractures who were referred to our unit for further treatment. A control group, consisting of 220 age- and sex-matched individuals (non-smokers with closed ankle fractures), was identified for comparative analysis. We collected clinical data, including pre-existing comorbidities, Lauge-Hansen fracture classification, necessity for surgery, and the surgical procedures performed.

The primary outcomes investigated were the time required for fracture union and wound healing. Secondary outcomes included postoperative complications such as prolonged pain, bleeding, swelling, infection, compartment syndrome, and neurovascular impairment, as well as the incidence of delayed union, non-union, and the need for further intervention. Both cohorts were monitored for a minimum of 24 months.

Results

Our analysis revealed that the surgical cohort of chronic heavy smokers exhibited a statistically significant delay in fracture union compared to both the conservatively managed smokers and the control group.

Further scrutiny of the surgical cohort of chronic smokers indicated a significant correlation between smoking and extended postoperative pain duration, persistent swelling at the fracture site, and both superficial and deep wound infections. Additionally, these patients experienced delays in both fracture union and wound healing when compared to the control group.

Similarly, the conservatively managed chronic smokers showed a marginal increase in the incidence of post-injury pain duration, extended swelling at the fracture site, and delayed union compared to the control group.

Conclusion

Patients who are chronic heavy smokers and require surgical intervention for ankle fractures should be made aware of their increased risk for delayed fracture union and poor wound healing. Orthopedic surgeons should proactively encourage these patients to participate in smoking cessation programs.