A Review of Pacific Salmon Hatcheries in British Columbia, Canada, and Interactions With Natural Populations

Abstract

Pacific salmon Oncorhynchus spp. hatcheries in British Columbia (BC) have been the major activity of the Salmonid Enhancement Program since 1977. However, the present diminished abundance of Pacific salmon and loss of fisheries in BC called for a review of hatchery effectiveness. The Pacific Salmon Foundation conducted a review resulting in 15 reports publicly available on the Pacific Salmon Foundation marine science website. The review includes evaluations of effectiveness of hatchery production, evidence of interactions with natural salmon populations (including rebuilding natural populations with hatchery-produced salmon), and future opportunities via genomics. Beyond the estimation of juvenile production and contribution to catches and spawning escapements, the ability to assess effectiveness was limited. The assessments of interactions provided a few examples of positive outcomes, but most were negative. The lack of comparative assessments in purely wild populations seriously limits interpretations of hatchery–wild interactions. Future evaluations of the hatchery effectiveness require more quantitative and integrated assessments of hatchery and wild salmon, open data sharing for public review or research, and related studies could benefit from application of new genomic technologies. This paper presents recommendations to address these needs and calls for regularized reviews of the Salmonid Enhancement Program and its net value to sustainability of BC's Pacific salmon.