Immunohistochemistry as an adjunct for challenging histological patterns of borderline Brenner tumors: An illustrative study of 4 cases

Abstract

Borderline Brenner tumors (BBT) have a range of morphology that shows considerable overlap with that of malignant Brenner tumors (MBT). In particular, two histological patterns of BBT can be particularly challenging: 1) BBT with intraepithelial carcinoma (BBT-IEC) and 2) BBT with a small nested pattern (BBT-SNP). BBT-IEC is characterized by a tumor with the low-power non-infiltrative silhouette of a conventional BBT, but with increased cytological atypia and mitotic activity similar to that of MBT. Conversely, BBT-SNP is characterized by a complex proliferation of small tumor nests that closely resemble the infiltrative growth pattern of MBT, but without the obligate cytologic atypia and mitotic activity of MBT.

We suggest that the combination of p16, p53 and Ki-67 may be helpful in distinguishing these 2 patterns of BBT from both conventional BBT and from MBT. While both conventional BBT and BBT-IEC show a null pattern of p16 expression, our case of BBT-IEC showed aberrant p53 overexpression, albeit with a maturation pattern similar to that described for TP53 mutant mucinous ovarian carcinoma and differentiated vulvar intraepithelial neoplasia (dVIN). Similarly, while BBT-SNP shows an infiltrative-like growth pattern similar to that of MBT, our case also showed a wild-type pattern of p53 expression and a Ki-67 proliferative index similar to areas with conventional BBT histology. In conclusion, in our small case series, we show that the use of immunohistochemistry for p53 and Ki-67 may help to distinguish challenging patterns of BBT from MBT. Further studies are needed to validate this finding in a larger case cohort.