Accuracy of second and third molar maturity indices, Olze, Haavikko, and Demirjian methods for 14- and 16-year-old age thresholds assessment in Croatian children and adolescents.

Abstract

This study explores the reliability of four established legal age threshold estimation approaches in a Croatian sample. We applied Haavikko stages, Demirjian stages, Olze's third molar eruption stages, and second and third molar maturity indices measurement in 593 orthopantomograms of Croatian children and adolescents aged 11.00-20.99 years old. The left mandibular second and third molar were assessed. Logistic regression analysis was conducted to test the significance of predictive variables. Logistic Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were performed to evaluate the classification ability of variables for estimating 14- and 16-year-old thresholds. The areas under the ROC curve (AUC), accuracy (Acc), sensitivity (Se), specificity (Sp), Positive Likelihood Ratio (LR +), Negative Likelihood Ratio (LR-), and Bayes post-test probability (Bayes PTP) were calculated to evaluate classification performance. Results suggest that the combination of I_2M&I_3M is the best classifier for the 14-year-old threshold (AUC = 0.879); for males alone, I_2M is an even better classifier (AUC = 0.881). The highest Acc 80.1% (95%CI, 75.9%-83.9%), Bayes PTP 86.5% (95%CI, 82.8%-89.7%) and Sp 88.9% (95%CI, 83.0%-93.3%) were by I_3M < 0.81 & I_2M < 0.03 in total samples; the highest Acc 86.1% (80.6%- 90.6%), Bayes PTP 87.2% (95%CI, 81.7%- 91.4%) and Sp 87.8% (95%CI, 78.2%- 94.3%) were by I_2M < 0.01 in males, Acc of Haavikko Ac and Demirjian H stage in second molar is very close with slightly lower Bayes PTP and Sp. I_3M is a good classifier for 16-year-old threshold (AUC = 0.889). The cut-off value I_3M < 0.34 can be used to classify the 16-year-old threshold with Acc of 80.6% (95%CI, 77.2%-83.7%), Sp of 83.4% (95%CI, 79.0%-87.3%), and 81.7% (95%CI, 78.4%-84.8%) Bayes PTP. In conclusion, to classify the 14-year-old threshold, a pair of cut-off values I_3M < 0.81 & I_2M < 0.03 can be used in Croatian females; I_2M < 0.01, Demirjian H stage, Haavikko Ac stage in second molar, and the pair I_3M < 0.81 & I_2M < 0.03 can all be used in Croatian males. I_3M < 0.34 can classify the 16-year-old threshold in Croatian populations.