Dependability Analysis of the Negative-Sequence Turn-to-Turn Fault Protection Schemes for MMC-HVDC Converter Transformers

Abstract

This paper addresses two complex areas of research: the detection of turn-to-turn faults (TTF) in power transformers and the impact of inverter-based resources on the TTF protection scheme operation. Detecting turn-to-turn faults in power transformers by protection algorithms poses a challenge due to the minimal fault currents observed at transformer terminals. Yet, the demand for dependable TTF protection is very high because of the high fault currents inside the shorted turns and the resulting damage consequences. On the other hand, for such sensitive protection, adverse conditions such as transformer inrush currents or CT errors may lead to protection maloperation. Moreover, the fault current characteristic of the inverter-based source infeed is very different compared to the synchronous machine infeed, particularly concerning the negative-sequence current used in the TTF protection schemes, which calls for thorough research analysis. A simulation model of the converter transformer capable of simulating TTFs, and the Modular Multilevel Converter (MMC) for a High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission link, has been developed. The test results of turn-to-turn fault protection schemes in inverter-based generation-dominated power systems compared to the synchronous generator infeed are presented. The negative-sequence current protection quantities are analysed in more detail for TTFs with small and large number of shorted turns, i.e. without and with reactive negative-sequence current injection by the MMC control. Finally, the paper assesses the dependability of the transformer differential protection and sensitive TTF protection schemes in detecting faults with different numbers of shorted turns and fault resistance for TTFs occurring in the star and delta winding of the converter transformer.