Do interspecific differences in morphology influence foraging efficiency of juvenile crappie?

Abstract

Sympatric black crappie (Pomoxis nigromaculatus Lesueur in Cuvier and Valenciennes, 1829) and white crappie (P. annularis Rafinesque, 1818) often differ in ecological performance, such that white crappie outnumber black crappie in turbid waterbodies and black crappie predominate in clear waters with abundant cover. Recent work suggests this performance difference is driven by juvenile white crappie having a limnetic body form and juvenile black crappie having a littoral body form, resulting in differential predation mortality between the species within open-water and vegetated environments. We tested whether these morphologies also lead to interspecific differences in foraging efficiency between the congeners in structure and open water. Juvenile black crappie spent more time pursuing fish prey than white crappie across all trials, suggesting that energetic gains of piscivory may differ between species. However, both species had similar capture efficiencies when attacking fathead minnows (Pimephales promelas Rafinesque, 1820) within vegetated and open-water habitats. We conclude that variation in morphology between juvenile black crappie and white crappie does not have a large influence on foraging efficiency, at least on fish prey, in dense cover or open water, and suggest their performance in sympatry is likely not driven by predatory capabilities at the onset of piscivory within these different environmental contexts. Instead, the relationship between morphology and predator evasion may drive the distribution and relative abundance of crappie species within sympatric populations.