The relationship between departmental culture and resuscitation-related moral distress among inpatient medical departments physicians and nurses

Abstract

Background

While moral distress frequency and intensity have been reported among clinicians around the world, resuscitations have not been well documented as its source.

Objectives

to examine the relationship between intensity and frequency of resuscitation- related moral distress and departmental culture among nurses and physicians working in inpatient medical departments.

Methods

This was a cross-sectional, prospective study of medical inpatient department staff from three hospitals. Questionnaires included a demographic and work characteristics questionnaire, the Resuscitation-Related Moral Distress Scale (a revised version of the Moral Distress Scale measuring frequency and intensity of moral distress), and a Departmental Culture Questionnaire.

Results

64 physicians and 201 nurses (response rate 64 %) participated, with a mean of 8.4 (SD = 5.1) resuscitations in the previous 6 months. Highest moral distress frequency scores were reported for items related to family demands or having no medical decision related to life- saving interventions for dying patients. Highest moral distress intensity scores were found when appropriate care for deteriorating patients was not given due poor staffing and when witnessing a resuscitation that could have been prevented had the staff identified the deterioration on time. Most participants strongly agreed (n = 228, 86.0 %) that their department medical director considers it important for staff to determine patients’ end-of-life preferences and that quality of life is of the highest value.

Conclusions

Clinicians working in medical inpatient department suffer from moderate frequency and high intensity levels of resuscitation-related moral distress. There was a statistically significant association between intention to leave employment with resuscitation-related moral distress frequency and intensity.