Neural evidence of core foundations and conceptual change in preschool numeracy

Abstract

Symbolic numeracy first emerges as children learn the meanings of number words and how to use them to precisely count sets of objects. This development starts before children enter school and forms a foundation for lifelong mathematics achievement. Despite its importance, exactly how children acquire this basic knowledge is unclear. Here we test competing theories of early number learning by measuring event-related brain potentials during a novel number word-quantity comparison task in 3–4-year-old preschool children (N = 128). We find several qualitative differences in neural processing of number by conceptual stage of development. Specifically, we find differences in early attention-related parietal electrophysiology (N1), suggesting that less conceptually advanced children process arrays as individual objects and more advanced children distribute attention over the entire set. Subsequently, we find that only more conceptually advanced children show later-going frontal (N2) sensitivity to the numerical-distance relationship between the number word and visual quantity. The nature of this response suggested that exact rather than approximate numerical meanings were being associated with number words over frontal sites. No evidence of numerical distance effects was observed over posterior scalp sites. Together these results suggest that children may engage parallel individuation of objects to learn the meanings of the first few number words, but, ultimately, create new exact cardinal value representations for number words that cannot be defined in terms of core, nonverbal number systems. More broadly, these results document an interaction between attentional and general cognitive mechanisms in cognitive development.

Research Highlights

• Conceptual development in numeracy is associated with a shift in attention from objects to sets.
• Children acquire meanings of the first few number words through associations with parallel attentional individuation of objects.
• Understanding of cardinality is associated with attentional processing of sets rather than individuals.
• Brain signatures suggest children attribute exact rather than approximate numerical meanings to the first few number words.
• Number-quantity relationship processing for the first few number words is evident in frontal but not parietal scalp electrophysiology of young children.