Looking to "Level the Field": A Qualitative Study of How Clinicians Operationalize Social Determinants in Critical Care.

Abstract

Rationale: Current critical care practice does not integrate social determinants of health (SDOH) in systematic or standardized ways. Routine assessment of SDOH in the intensive care unit (ICU) may improve clinical decision making, patient- and family-centered outcomes, and clinician well-being. Objective: Given that the appropriateness and feasibility of SDOH assessment in the ICU is unknown, we aimed to understand how ICU clinicians think about and use SDOH. Methods: We conducted semistructured interviews with clinicians focused on barriers to and facilitators of assessing SDOH during critical illness and perceptions of screening for SDOH in the ICU. We used chart-stimulated recall to assist clinicians in reflecting on how SDOH applied to and was used in patients' care. After deidentifying interviews, we analyzed transcripts guided by a thematic analysis approach using a combination of inductive and deductive coding, the latter framed within the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention SDOH Healthy People framework. Results: We completed interviews with 30 clinicians in a variety of professional roles. The majority of clinicians self-identified as men (n = 17; 56.7%) of White race (n = 25; 83.3%). Clinicians contextualize their use of SDOH within three frames of reference: 1) their own identity and experiences; 2) their relationships and communication with patients and caregivers; and 3) immediate structures of care around ICU patients, including clinician advocacy, care transitions, and readmission. Clinicians identified that discussing SDOH could allow them to recognize bias faced by their patients, elucidate drivers of critical illness, and navigate communication with patients' caregivers. Clinicians worried about ICU-specific factors impeding the discussion of SDOH, including time constraints and acuity, high stakes and emotions, and negative anticipatory emotions. Conclusions: Clinicians gather SDOH during critical illness both to understand their patients' stories and to provide individualized care, which may lead to better clinician satisfaction and patient- and family-centered care outcomes. Educational and operational efforts to increase SDOH assessment and use in critical care should also gather and integrate the perspectives of patients and caregivers regarding the collection and use of SDOH in the ICU.