Functional and Aesthetic Comparison between Grafts and Local Flaps in Non-Melanoma Skin Cancer Surgery of the Face: A Cohort Study

Abstract

Background

Non-melanoma skin cancers represent more than 90 % of malignant skin tumors, with an incidence of 19.46 cases/100,000 people per year in Italy; however, their real incidence is underestimated. Although there are several therapeutic strategies, the only one that can guarantee a 95 % healing rate and the possibility of performing histological examination is surgical excision with subsequent reconstruction of the injured area with direct closure and with skin graft, local, regional, or free flaps in cases involving greater damage.

Material and Methods

Fifty-four patients underwent post-oncological head/face reconstructive surgery with skin graft or local flap between November 2021 and February 2023. The aesthetic outcomes (and the subsequent impact on the patients’ lives) were assessed using the Vancouver Scar Scale, Manchester Scar Scale, and Visual Analog Scale with scars ranked by three independent surgeon observers.

Results

Patients who received reconstruction with local flaps demonstrated improved aesthetic and functional satisfaction, as well as improved aesthetic evaluation by independent surgeons.

Conclusions

The use of local flaps permits a more pleasing reconstruction (functionally and aesthetically) of post-oncological tissue defects of the face.