The Role of Repeated Surgical Resections for Recurrent Brain Metastases in Older Population

Abstract

Background and Objectives: The impact of surgery for recurrent brain metastases in elderly patients has been the object of debate due to limited information in the literature. We analyzed clinical outcome and survival of elderly patients with recurrent brain metastases in order to assess potentially beneficial role of surgery. Materials and methods: In total, 219 patients with recurrent brain metastases between 2007 and 2022 were identified, of which 95 underwent re-resection; 83 patients aged 65 and older were analyzed. A survival analysis was performed, and clinical outcomes were evaluated. Results: The median survival time after surgery for recurrent brain metastases was 6 months (95CI 4–10) in older patients and 8 (95CI 7–9) in younger patients (p = 0.619). Out of all the older patients, 33 who underwent surgical resection showed prolonged survival compared with patients who did not receive surgical resection (median: 14, 95CI 8–19 vs. 4, 95CI 4–7, p = 0.011). All patients had preoperative Karnofsky performance scores of >70, which did not deteriorate after surgery (87.02 ± 5.76 vs. 85 ± 6.85; p = 0.055). In the univariate analysis, complete cytoreduction was a favorable prognostic factor. The tumor volume, the number of metastases, extracranial disease progression, adjuvant radiation, and systemic therapy did not affect survival in this cohort. Conclusions: Patients aged 65 and older benefit from neurosurgical resections of recurrent brain metastases. Survival did not differ from that in younger patients, which can be explained by a better preoperative functional status. Moreover, independent of the extent of resection, older patients who underwent surgery showed better survival than patients who did not receive surgical treatment. Complete cytoreduction was a favorable prognostic marker.