Effect of treatment of transverse maxillary deficiency using rapid palatal expansion on oral health-related quality of life in children: complementary results for a controlled clinical trial

Abstract

Objective

To evaluate the effect of rapid palatal expansion (RPE) using Haas-type expanders on children’s oral health-related quality of life (OHRQOL) and compare said effect with that previously reported for the use of Hyrax-type expanders.

Materials and methods

Forty participants aged 8–10 years with transverse maxillary deficiency were treated using Haas appliances. OHRQOL was measured using the CPQ_8 − 10 before RPE, during RPE (T₁), at the end of RPE (T₂), and 1 month after appliance removal (T₃). Generalized mixed models were fitted to assess the effect of the Haas-type expander compared to previously collected data (a nontreated and a Hyrax-type expander-treated group).

Results

RPE with Haas-type appliances had a negative impact on overall OHRQOL at T₁ and T₂ (P = 0.001), and a positive impact at T₃ (P = 0.001). The Haas-type expander had a significantly greater negative impact on OHRQOL than the Hyrax-type appliance during RPE. At T₁, overall scores using the Haas-type expander were 1.08 times the scores using the Hyrax-type expander (i.e., 8% increase; 95% CI, 1.01–1.17; P = 0.033). Patients using the Haas appliance had 1.24 times the scores of those using Hyrax-type devices for the oral symptoms domain at T₁ (i.e., 24% increase; 95% CI, 1.06–1.46; P = 0.009).

Conclusions

Correction of the transverse maxillary deficiency by RPE using the Haas appliance in children 8–10 years improves OHRQOL. The Haas- and Hyrax-type devices temporarily worsen OHRQOL during treatment, however, the negative impact is less with the Hyrax-type expander than with the Haas-type expander, because it causes fewer negative oral symptoms.

Clinical relevance

From a patient-centered perspective, the use of the Hyrax over the Haas appliance may be suggested as it causes less negative oral symptoms during use.