Aliado - A design concept of AI for decision support in oncological liver surgery

Abstract

Background

The interest in artificial intelligence (AI) is increasing. Systematic reviews suggest that there are many machine learning algorithms in surgery, however, only a minority of the studies integrate AI applications in clinical workflows. Our objective was to design and evaluate a concept to use different kinds of AI for decision support in oncological liver surgery along the treatment path.

Methods

In an exploratory co-creation between design experts, surgeons, and data scientists, pain points along the treatment path were identified. Potential designs for AI-assisted solutions were developed and iteratively refined. Finally, an evaluation of the design concept was performed with n = 20 surgeons to get feedback on the different functionalities and evaluate the usability with the System Usability Scale (SUS). Participating surgeons had a mean of 14.0 ± 5.0 years of experience after graduation.

Results

The design concept was named “Aliado”. Five different scenarios were identified where AI could support surgeons. Mean score of SUS was 68.2 ( ± 13.6 SD). The highest valued functionalities were “individualized prediction of survival, short-term mortality and morbidity”, and “individualized recommendation of surgical strategy”.

Conclusion

Aliado is a design prototype that shows how AI could be integrated into the clinical workflow. Even without a fleshed out user interface, the SUS already yielded borderline good results. Expert surgeons rated the functionalities favorably, and most of them expressed their willingness to work with a similar application in the future. Thus, Aliado can serve as a surgical vision of how an ideal AI-based assistance could look like.