Practice variations, trends, and outcomes of drain use in thyroidectomy: A NSQIP study

Abstract

Background

The benefit of drains remains unclear and variable among thyroid surgeons. This study examines the utility and trend in drain use after thyroidectomy.

Method

This is a retrospective cross-sectional study utilizing a pooled sample of thyroidectomy patients from the 2016–2019 NSQIP. The impact of drain use on outcomes of interest (rate of postoperative neck hematoma (PNH)–primary outcome, and length-of-stay (LOS)–secondary outcome), as well as year-over-year and practice variations were evaluated using inverse-probability-weighted-regression adjustment and multivariable logistic regression analyses.

Results

Of 24,370 patients, 6673(27.4 ​%) received drains. The average LOS and PNH rates were 27.3 ​h and 1.87 %, respectively. Drain use increased year-over-year for concomitant neck dissections (OR ​= ​1.08,p ​= ​0.002). Year-over-year odds of drain use trended down across specialties (OR ​= ​0.96,p ​= ​0.005); however, ENT used drains more frequently than General Surgeons (RR ​= ​3.06, 95%CI ​= ​2.91–3.22). Drains were associated with longer LOS (mean-difference ​= ​9.6hrs, 95%CI 8.51–10.62) with no effect on PNH rates (RR ​= ​0.96,p ​< ​0.05).

Conclusion

Drain use is decreasing, but practice variations across specialties persist. Post-thyroidectomy drain use was associated with longer LOS with no effect on PNHR.