Inclusion of Veterans Health Administration hospitals in Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services Overall Hospital Quality Star Ratings.

Abstract

Background/objective: The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) Overall Hospital Quality Star Rating, established in 2016, is a summary of publicly available quality information for acute care hospitals. In July 2023, Veterans Health Administration (VHA) hospitals became eligible to receive a CMS Overall Hospital Quality Star Rating for the first time. Our objective was to compare performance in quality ratings among VHA and non-VHA hospitals.

Methods: We used the hospital quality measure scores posted to Care Compare on Medicare.gov as of January 2023 as our primary data set. We conducted a pair of analyses to characterize the performance of VHA hospitals compared to non-VHA hospitals: an overall analysis including all rated hospitals, and a matched analysis in which only a single nearby hospital was included for each VHA hospital.

Results: Of the 4518 non-VHA hospitals, 2962 (65.6%) received a Star Rating, compared to 114 (84%) of 136 VHA hospitals. VHA hospitals tended to receive higher ratings overall (one-star: 8%; two-star: 11%; three-star: 14%; four-star: 35%; five-star: 32%) than non-VHA (one-star: 8%; two-star: 22%; three-star: 29%; four-star: 26%; five-star: 15%). A similar pattern was observed in the matched analysis.

Conclusions: VHA hospitals tended to perform better on the Overall Star Rating compared to non-VHA hospitals, as evidenced by being more likely to receive a four- or five-star rating. The eligibility of VHA hospitals to receive an Overall Star Rating signifies an important addition to the program that will allow Veterans to make more informed healthcare decisions.