{"title":"Roughness-induced transition and turbulent wedge spreading","authors":"Alexandre Berger, Edward White","doi":"10.1007/s00348-024-03909-7","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><p>Boundary layer transition triggered by a discrete roughness element generates a turbulent wedge that spreads laterally as it proceeds downstream. The historical literature reports the spreading half angle is approximately 6<span>\\(^{\\circ }\\)</span> in zero-pressure gradient flows regardless of Reynolds number and roughness shape. Recent simulations and experiments have sought to explain the lateral spreading mechanism and have observed high- and low-speed streaks along the flanks of the wedge that appear central to the spreading process. To better elucidate the roles of Reynolds number and of streaks, a naphthalene flow visualization survey and hotwire measurements are conducted over a wider range of Reynolds numbers and longer streamwise domain than previous experiments. The naphthalene results show that while the mean spreading angle is consistent with the historical literature, there may be a weak dependency on <i>x</i>-based Reynolds number, which emerges as a result of the large sample size of the survey. The distance between the roughness element and the wedge origin exhibits a clear trend with the roughness–height-based Reynolds number. The hotwire measurements explain that this difference originates from whether breakdown occurs first in the central lobe or flanking streaks of the turbulent wedge. This observation highlights different transition dynamics at play within the supercritical regime. In agreement with past experiments, the hotwire measurements reveal that breakdown occurs in the wall normal shear layer above low-speed streaks. Due to the elongated streamwise extent of this experiment, secondary streak dynamics are also uncovered. A high-speed streak is produced directly downstream of the initiating low-speed streak. Subsequently, a new low-speed streak is observed outboard of the previous high-speed streak. This self-sustaining process is the driving mechanism of turbulent wedge spreading.</p></div>","PeriodicalId":554,"journal":{"name":"Experiments in Fluids","volume":"65 11","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":2.3000,"publicationDate":"2024-11-02","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Experiments in Fluids","FirstCategoryId":"5","ListUrlMain":"https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00348-024-03909-7","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"工程技术","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"ENGINEERING, MECHANICAL","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Boundary layer transition triggered by a discrete roughness element generates a turbulent wedge that spreads laterally as it proceeds downstream. The historical literature reports the spreading half angle is approximately 6\(^{\circ }\) in zero-pressure gradient flows regardless of Reynolds number and roughness shape. Recent simulations and experiments have sought to explain the lateral spreading mechanism and have observed high- and low-speed streaks along the flanks of the wedge that appear central to the spreading process. To better elucidate the roles of Reynolds number and of streaks, a naphthalene flow visualization survey and hotwire measurements are conducted over a wider range of Reynolds numbers and longer streamwise domain than previous experiments. The naphthalene results show that while the mean spreading angle is consistent with the historical literature, there may be a weak dependency on x-based Reynolds number, which emerges as a result of the large sample size of the survey. The distance between the roughness element and the wedge origin exhibits a clear trend with the roughness–height-based Reynolds number. The hotwire measurements explain that this difference originates from whether breakdown occurs first in the central lobe or flanking streaks of the turbulent wedge. This observation highlights different transition dynamics at play within the supercritical regime. In agreement with past experiments, the hotwire measurements reveal that breakdown occurs in the wall normal shear layer above low-speed streaks. Due to the elongated streamwise extent of this experiment, secondary streak dynamics are also uncovered. A high-speed streak is produced directly downstream of the initiating low-speed streak. Subsequently, a new low-speed streak is observed outboard of the previous high-speed streak. This self-sustaining process is the driving mechanism of turbulent wedge spreading.
由离散粗糙度元素引发的边界层过渡会产生一个湍流楔,该湍流楔在顺流而下时会横向扩散。据历史文献报道,在零压力梯度流中,无论雷诺数和粗糙度形状如何,扩散半角大约为 6(^{\circ }\)。最近的模拟和实验试图解释横向扩张机制,并观察到沿着楔形侧面的高速和低速条纹似乎是扩张过程的核心。为了更好地阐明雷诺数和条纹的作用,我们在比以往实验更宽的雷诺数范围和更长的流域内进行了萘流可视化调查和热线测量。萘的测量结果表明,虽然平均扩展角与历史文献一致,但可能与基于 x 的雷诺数有微弱的相关性,这也是调查样本量大的结果。粗糙度元素与楔形原点之间的距离与基于粗糙度高度的雷诺数呈明显的趋势。热丝测量结果表明,这种差异源于湍流楔的中央叶片或侧翼条纹是否首先发生破裂。这一观测结果凸显了超临界状态下不同的过渡动力学。与过去的实验一致,热丝测量显示,击穿发生在低速条纹上方的壁面法向剪切层。由于本次实验的流向范围较长,还发现了次级条纹动力学。在开始的低速条纹的正下游产生了一条高速条纹。随后,在前一条高速条纹的外侧又观测到一条新的低速条纹。这种自我维持过程是湍流楔形扩展的驱动机制。
期刊介绍:
Experiments in Fluids examines the advancement, extension, and improvement of new techniques of flow measurement. The journal also publishes contributions that employ existing experimental techniques to gain an understanding of the underlying flow physics in the areas of turbulence, aerodynamics, hydrodynamics, convective heat transfer, combustion, turbomachinery, multi-phase flows, and chemical, biological and geological flows. In addition, readers will find papers that report on investigations combining experimental and analytical/numerical approaches.