Forensic Pathologist Testimony, Part 1: Common Questions and Considerations.

Abstract

Introduction: Forensic pathologists are the only medical specialists who routinely testify in courts of law as part of their occupation. As such, one element of their training involves learning how to testify responsibly and competently. Individuals qualified as experts are permitted to offer opinions in order to assist the triers of fact.

Results: We review the forensic pathologist's primary role as an expert witness which is to lay out concepts clearly, methodically, and objectively, in medicine, pathophysiology, toxicology, and injury, to convey these concepts with understandable, plain language, and to explain how certain evidence, physical, medical, and historical, supports their conclusions and/or presents limitations.

Discussion: We discuss various components about testifying in court, some common expert questions posed to the forensic pathologist, and what concepts and facts they might consider when answering them. We do not offer a prescription as to how one should answer these questions specifically, but rather we provide a single resource that summarizes some of the key issues that may arise in court for the forensic pathologist.