Variation in Recommended Treatment Strategies Among American Surgeons for Actual Adult Traumatic Brachial Plexus Injury Cases.

Abstract

Purpose: The surgical management of adult traumatic brachial plexus injuries (BPI) is challenging, with no consensus on optimal strategies. This study aimed to gather preferred reconstructive strategies from BPI surgeons for actual cases from a multicenter cohort to identify areas of agreement.

Methods: Four case files (history, physical examination, and imaging and electrodiagnostic testing results) were distributed to eight self-designated Level IV expert BPI surgeons in the United States. Each surgeon independently reviewed the cases and provided a preferred reconstructive plan via free text response.

Results: For a pan-plexus case after blunt trauma (67 years old; 3 months from injury): three surgeons recommended nerve grafting upper trunk roots to distal targets. There was disagreement in shoulder reconstruction: one suggested early shoulder fusion, two preferred cranial nerve XI to suprascapular nerve (SSN) transfer, and two anticipated future salvage shoulder fusion. For elbow reconstruction, six surgeons preferred intercostal nerve to musculocutaneous nerve transfer. For an upper trunk injury from a motorcycle accident (33 years old; 6 months from injury), only one surgeon recommended nerve grafting, six preferred XI to SSN transfer, all recommended triceps-to-axillary transfer, and all but one favored a double fascicular transfer.

Conclusions: There is inconsistency in the use of nerve grafting for BPI patients, especially in pan-plexus injuries where options are limited. Variability exists in shoulder reconstruction and stability management, with some advocating early glenohumeral arthrodesis. Although single fascicular and triceps-to-axillary transfers are consistently favored, there is no consensus for restoring shoulder and elbow function when intraplexal transfers are unavailable.

Clinical relevance: This study highlights substantial variability in surgical approaches to BPI among experts, underscoring the need for standardized treatment protocols. Understanding these diverse strategies can inform clinical decision making and help develop more uniform guidelines to improve patient outcomes.