{"title":"CO2 geological storage in subsurface aquifers as a function of brine salinity: A field-scale numerical investigation","authors":"Haiyang Zhang , Yihuai Zhang , Muhammad Arif","doi":"10.1016/j.geoen.2024.213505","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><div>Subsurface aquifers demonstrate a broad range of salinities and salt compositions, affecting the physicochemical characteristics of the CO<sub>2</sub>/brine/rock systems, which in turn, influence the CO<sub>2</sub> trapping of the aquifer formation. Available simulation studies generally focus on single NaCl systems and do not adequately account for the variations in salt types. In this study, the impact of salinity and salt type on several key parameters, including wettability, interfacial tension, brine properties, diffusion, and capillary pressure, were considered within the context of underground CO<sub>2</sub> storage. We conducted pore network modeling to assess the impact of salinity (i.e., pure water, 1 M (molality), 3 M, and 5 M) and salt type (i.e., NaCl, CaCl<sub>2</sub>, and MgCl<sub>2</sub>) on the residual trapping behaviors. Subsequently, these findings were utilized in field-scale simulations to assess the influence of various salinities and salt types on the CO<sub>2</sub> trapping capacity in a single salt brine system. The pore network modeling results showed that residual CO<sub>2</sub> saturation decreases in higher salinity conditions, with the lowest value in MgCl<sub>2</sub> brine system. In field-scale simulations incorporating residual trapping alone, the residual trapping capacity decreases in higher salinity NaCl brine systems. However, in high salinity MgCl<sub>2</sub> brine, increased viscosity and density lead to a widespread CO<sub>2</sub> plume, leading to an increased residual trapping capacity. This plume spread difference also influences the amount of dissolved CO<sub>2</sub> in scenarios considering dissolution trapping alone. When considering both trapping mechanisms, our observations indicate that a decrease in dissolution trapping under high salinity and divalent cations conditions leads to enhanced residual trapping (e.g., ∼51.56% for 5 M MgCl<sub>2</sub>) - suggesting an interplay or codependency between these two mechanisms. The influences of diffusion and capillary pressure on the CO<sub>2</sub> geo-storage trapping capacity are also investigated. Overall, an aquifer containing lower salinity brine composed of monovalent ions exhibits lower residual trapping, greater dissolution trapping, and lower mobile CO<sub>2</sub>. Especially, the pure water system exhibits the lowest percentage of mobile CO<sub>2</sub> (∼13.72%). We also highlight that this impact is not governed by the corresponding wettability shift alone; rather, the physical properties of native brine (i.e., viscosity and density) play a part too. The findings help evaluate the CO<sub>2</sub> storage potential of aquifers and thus assist in de-risking large-scale storage projects.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":100578,"journal":{"name":"Geoenergy Science and Engineering","volume":"245 ","pages":"Article 213505"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2024-11-17","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Geoenergy Science and Engineering","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2949891024008753","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ENERGY & FUELS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Subsurface aquifers demonstrate a broad range of salinities and salt compositions, affecting the physicochemical characteristics of the CO2/brine/rock systems, which in turn, influence the CO2 trapping of the aquifer formation. Available simulation studies generally focus on single NaCl systems and do not adequately account for the variations in salt types. In this study, the impact of salinity and salt type on several key parameters, including wettability, interfacial tension, brine properties, diffusion, and capillary pressure, were considered within the context of underground CO2 storage. We conducted pore network modeling to assess the impact of salinity (i.e., pure water, 1 M (molality), 3 M, and 5 M) and salt type (i.e., NaCl, CaCl2, and MgCl2) on the residual trapping behaviors. Subsequently, these findings were utilized in field-scale simulations to assess the influence of various salinities and salt types on the CO2 trapping capacity in a single salt brine system. The pore network modeling results showed that residual CO2 saturation decreases in higher salinity conditions, with the lowest value in MgCl2 brine system. In field-scale simulations incorporating residual trapping alone, the residual trapping capacity decreases in higher salinity NaCl brine systems. However, in high salinity MgCl2 brine, increased viscosity and density lead to a widespread CO2 plume, leading to an increased residual trapping capacity. This plume spread difference also influences the amount of dissolved CO2 in scenarios considering dissolution trapping alone. When considering both trapping mechanisms, our observations indicate that a decrease in dissolution trapping under high salinity and divalent cations conditions leads to enhanced residual trapping (e.g., ∼51.56% for 5 M MgCl2) - suggesting an interplay or codependency between these two mechanisms. The influences of diffusion and capillary pressure on the CO2 geo-storage trapping capacity are also investigated. Overall, an aquifer containing lower salinity brine composed of monovalent ions exhibits lower residual trapping, greater dissolution trapping, and lower mobile CO2. Especially, the pure water system exhibits the lowest percentage of mobile CO2 (∼13.72%). We also highlight that this impact is not governed by the corresponding wettability shift alone; rather, the physical properties of native brine (i.e., viscosity and density) play a part too. The findings help evaluate the CO2 storage potential of aquifers and thus assist in de-risking large-scale storage projects.
地下含水层的盐度和盐分组成范围很广,会影响二氧化碳/卤水/岩石系统的物理化学特性,进而影响含水层的二氧化碳捕集能力。现有的模拟研究一般侧重于单一的氯化钠系统,没有充分考虑盐类的变化。本研究以地下二氧化碳封存为背景,考虑了盐度和盐类型对几个关键参数的影响,包括润湿性、界面张力、盐水特性、扩散和毛细管压力。我们进行了孔隙网络建模,以评估盐度(即纯水、1 M(摩尔)、3 M 和 5 M)和盐类型(即 NaCl、CaCl2 和 MgCl2)对残留捕集行为的影响。随后,利用这些发现进行了实地模拟,以评估不同盐度和盐类型对单一盐卤系统中二氧化碳捕集能力的影响。孔隙网络建模结果表明,残余二氧化碳饱和度在盐度较高的条件下会降低,在氯化镁盐水系统中最低。在仅考虑残留捕集的实地规模模拟中,残留捕集能力在盐度较高的氯化钠盐水系统中降低。然而,在高盐度的氯化镁盐水中,粘度和密度的增加会导致二氧化碳羽流的扩散,从而提高残留捕集能力。在仅考虑溶解捕集的情况下,这种羽流扩散差异也会影响溶解的二氧化碳量。当同时考虑两种捕集机制时,我们的观察结果表明,在高盐度和二价阳离子条件下,溶解捕集的减少会导致剩余捕集能力的增强(例如,5 M MgCl2 时为 51.56%)--这表明这两种机制之间存在相互作用或相互依存关系。此外,还研究了扩散和毛细管压力对二氧化碳地质封存捕集能力的影响。总的来说,含盐量较低的盐水(由单价离子组成)含水层的残留捕集能力较低,溶解捕集能力较强,二氧化碳的流动性较低。特别是,纯水系统的移动 CO2 百分比最低(13.72%)。我们还强调,这种影响并不仅仅受制于相应的润湿性变化;相反,原生盐水的物理性质(即粘度和密度)也起到了一定的作用。这些发现有助于评估含水层的二氧化碳封存潜力,从而帮助降低大规模封存项目的风险。