Tailoring implementation strategies for the healthy actions and lifestyles to Avoid Dementia or Hispanos y el ALTo a la Demencia Program: Lessons learned from a survey study.
Sara Moukarzel, Carlos E E Araujo-Menendez, Eliza Galang, Zvinka Z Zlatar, Howard H Feldman, Sarah J Banks
{"title":"Tailoring implementation strategies for the healthy actions and lifestyles to Avoid Dementia or Hispanos y el ALTo a la Demencia Program: Lessons learned from a survey study.","authors":"Sara Moukarzel, Carlos E E Araujo-Menendez, Eliza Galang, Zvinka Z Zlatar, Howard H Feldman, Sarah J Banks","doi":"10.1016/j.tjpad.2024.100053","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><strong>Background: </strong>Healthy Actions and Lifestyles to Avoid Dementia Program (HALT-AD) or Hispanos y el ALTo a la Demencia is a recently-developed online educational platform to help individuals identify and modify their own dementia modifiable risk factors (MRF). In light of known challenges in recruiting and retaining diverse participants in research studies, there is a need to identify data-informed strategies that will contribute to effective outreach and tailored implementation of HALT-AD among its intended users of Hispanic and non-Hispanic midlife and older adults in the US.</p><p><strong>Objectives: </strong>To identify factors (i.e, demographic, medical, psychosocial and environmental) that may facilitate or impede effective program enrollment and participation.</p><p><strong>Design: </strong>Cross-sectional study SETTING: Data from an online and self-administered survey conducted between January and April 2023 PARTICIPANTS: Residents of California, predominately San Diego, who were 50 to 85 years old, with no dementia or Alzheimer's disease, proficient in English or Spanish and with enough technical ability to complete the survey electronically (n=157; 43% Hispanic). INTERVENTION (IF ANY): none MEASUREMENTS: RedCap was used to capture answers to closed and open-ended survey questions. Mixed-methods analysis was used: For quantitative data, descriptive statistics, comparisons by group (Hispanic/non-Hispanic), and exploratory factor analysis were conducted in SPSS. Thematic analysis with open coding in Excel was used for qualitative responses.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>Independent of ethnicity, participants' most preferred method of reach for recruitment was through a conversation with their doctor or with a family member or friend. Their least preferred method was receiving a Facebook advertisement especially among non-Hispanics. Interest in program participation did not differ by sociodemographic characteristics or self-rated satisfaction with individualized MRFs. Instead, having higher confidence in one's ability to commit to behavior change was significantly associated with higher interest in program participation. While a common theme to motivate both groups to participate was the potential to decrease dementia risk, non-Hispanics were motivated by the premise of supporting research and having a positive user experience. For program implementation, Hispanics were more likely to be interested in participating if live sessions, either online or in-person, were provided to offer support with making lifestyle changes as adjunct to completing online courses independently. In both groups, participation may be further facilitated by offering wearable devices which provide participants with feedback on lifestyle change progress.</p><p><strong>Conclusions: </strong>A \"one-size-fits-all\" approach to recruitment and implementation of HALT-AD may not be effective in enrolling and retaining participants in future studies or for clinical use. Instead, a tailored approach that accounts for personal and ethnically-dependent preferences may be more beneficial.</p>","PeriodicalId":22711,"journal":{"name":"The Journal of Prevention of Alzheimer's Disease","volume":" ","pages":"100053"},"PeriodicalIF":4.3000,"publicationDate":"2025-03-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"The Journal of Prevention of Alzheimer's Disease","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tjpad.2024.100053","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"2025/1/17 0:00:00","PubModel":"Epub","JCR":"Q2","JCRName":"BUSINESS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Background: Healthy Actions and Lifestyles to Avoid Dementia Program (HALT-AD) or Hispanos y el ALTo a la Demencia is a recently-developed online educational platform to help individuals identify and modify their own dementia modifiable risk factors (MRF). In light of known challenges in recruiting and retaining diverse participants in research studies, there is a need to identify data-informed strategies that will contribute to effective outreach and tailored implementation of HALT-AD among its intended users of Hispanic and non-Hispanic midlife and older adults in the US.
Objectives: To identify factors (i.e, demographic, medical, psychosocial and environmental) that may facilitate or impede effective program enrollment and participation.
Design: Cross-sectional study SETTING: Data from an online and self-administered survey conducted between January and April 2023 PARTICIPANTS: Residents of California, predominately San Diego, who were 50 to 85 years old, with no dementia or Alzheimer's disease, proficient in English or Spanish and with enough technical ability to complete the survey electronically (n=157; 43% Hispanic). INTERVENTION (IF ANY): none MEASUREMENTS: RedCap was used to capture answers to closed and open-ended survey questions. Mixed-methods analysis was used: For quantitative data, descriptive statistics, comparisons by group (Hispanic/non-Hispanic), and exploratory factor analysis were conducted in SPSS. Thematic analysis with open coding in Excel was used for qualitative responses.
Results: Independent of ethnicity, participants' most preferred method of reach for recruitment was through a conversation with their doctor or with a family member or friend. Their least preferred method was receiving a Facebook advertisement especially among non-Hispanics. Interest in program participation did not differ by sociodemographic characteristics or self-rated satisfaction with individualized MRFs. Instead, having higher confidence in one's ability to commit to behavior change was significantly associated with higher interest in program participation. While a common theme to motivate both groups to participate was the potential to decrease dementia risk, non-Hispanics were motivated by the premise of supporting research and having a positive user experience. For program implementation, Hispanics were more likely to be interested in participating if live sessions, either online or in-person, were provided to offer support with making lifestyle changes as adjunct to completing online courses independently. In both groups, participation may be further facilitated by offering wearable devices which provide participants with feedback on lifestyle change progress.
Conclusions: A "one-size-fits-all" approach to recruitment and implementation of HALT-AD may not be effective in enrolling and retaining participants in future studies or for clinical use. Instead, a tailored approach that accounts for personal and ethnically-dependent preferences may be more beneficial.
背景:以健康的行动和生活方式来避免痴呆症计划(HALT-AD)或Hispanos y el ALTo a la Demencia是一个最近开发的在线教育平台,旨在帮助个人识别和修改自己的痴呆症可改变风险因素(MRF)。鉴于招募和保留研究中不同参与者的已知挑战,有必要确定数据知情的策略,这将有助于在美国西班牙裔和非西班牙裔中年和老年人的预期用户中有效地推广和定制实施HALT-AD。目标:确定可能促进或阻碍有效的项目登记和参与的因素(即人口、医学、社会心理和环境)。设计:横断研究设置:数据来自于2023年1月至4月期间进行的在线和自我管理的调查参与者:加利福尼亚州居民,主要是圣地亚哥,年龄在50至85岁之间,无痴呆或阿尔茨海默病,精通英语或西班牙语,具有足够的技术能力以电子方式完成调查(n=157;43%的西班牙裔)。干预(如果有的话):无测量方法:RedCap被用来获取封闭式和开放式调查问题的答案。采用混合方法分析:定量资料采用描述性统计、分组比较(西班牙裔/非西班牙裔)、探索性因素分析等方法。在Excel中使用开放式编码进行专题分析进行定性反应。结果:与种族无关,参与者最喜欢的招募方法是通过与他们的医生或家庭成员或朋友交谈。他们最不喜欢的方法是接收Facebook广告,尤其是在非西班牙裔人群中。对项目参与的兴趣没有因社会人口统计学特征或对个性化mrf的自评满意度而异。相反,对自己改变行为的能力有更高的信心,与参与项目的兴趣显著相关。虽然激励两组人参与的共同主题是降低痴呆症风险的可能性,但非西班牙裔人的动机是支持研究和拥有积极的用户体验。在项目实施方面,西班牙裔更有可能有兴趣参加现场会议,无论是在线还是面对面,提供支持,改变生活方式,作为独立完成在线课程的辅助。在这两个群体中,通过提供可穿戴设备,为参与者提供生活方式改变进展的反馈,可能会进一步促进他们的参与。结论:“一刀切”的招募和实施HALT-AD的方法可能无法有效地招募和保留未来研究或临床使用的参与者。相反,考虑到个人和种族偏好的量身定制的方法可能更有益。
期刊介绍:
The JPAD Journal of Prevention of Alzheimer’Disease will publish reviews, original research articles and short reports to improve our knowledge in the field of Alzheimer prevention including: neurosciences, biomarkers, imaging, epidemiology, public health, physical cognitive exercise, nutrition, risk and protective factors, drug development, trials design, and heath economic outcomes.JPAD will publish also the meeting abstracts from Clinical Trial on Alzheimer Disease (CTAD) and will be distributed both in paper and online version worldwide.We hope that JPAD with your contribution will play a role in the development of Alzheimer prevention.