The Effect of Locking Head Inserts on the Biomechanical Properties of a 3.5-mm Broad Locking Compression Plate When Used in an Open Fracture-Gap Model.

Abstract

Objective:  To determine the effect of locking head inserts (LHI) on plate strain, stiffness, and deformation when applied to a 3.5-mm broad locking compression plate (LCP) in an open fracture-gap model.

Study design:  Six, 13-hole, 3.5-mm broad LCP were secured to epoxy bone models with a 10 mm central defect and 1 mm plate offset. Two peripheral locking screws were placed in each segment, with the remaining screw holes left unfilled. Three strain gauges were glued to each LCP at anticipated regions of maximum strain. Constructs underwent cyclic uniaxial loading at a rate of 20 mm/min to 400 N in three different configurations (Configuration 1: no LHI, Configuration 2: 3 LHI, Configuration 3: 9 LHI). LHI were tightened to 4 Nm of torque. A data acquisition system was used to collect implant strain during testing. Construct stiffness and deformation were recorded by the biomechanical testing machine.

Results:  Maximum implant strain was recorded at the central screw hole directly over the simulated fracture gap in all configurations (Mdn 1,837.3 µε [interquartile range: 1,805.1-1,862.0]). There was no difference in implant peak-to-peak strain with addition of LHI at all three gauges (Gauge 1 [p = 0.847], Gauge 2 [p = 0.847], Gauge 3 [p = 0.311]). Similarly, peak-to-peak displacement (p = 0.069) and axial construct stiffness (p = 0.311) did not change with the addition of LHI.

Conclusion:  The addition of LHI to a 3.5-mm broad LCP construct was not shown to have an effect on plate strain, stiffness, or deformation.