Respiratory distress after planned births compared to expectant management – Target trial emulation

Abstract

Objective

The primary aim of this study was to determine the appropriate gestational age for planned births by elective cesarean section (ECS) or induction of labor (IOL) in relation to no excess risk of neonatal respiratory distress.

Study design

Register-based Swedish cohort study including 575,817 singleton live births at 36 weeks or later. Births not eligible for vaginal delivery, preterm premature rupture of membranes and infants with congenital anomalies were excluded. The primary outcome was respiratory distress, and a secondary outcome was Apgar score <7 at five minutes. The risk of outcomes according to onset of birth was calculated for each day from gestational week 36 to 41 and compared with expectant management (EM), defined as births at least one day later.

Results

No excess risk of respiratory distress was found for ECS from 40 weeks and for IOL from 38 weeks compared with EM. At 37 weeks, the absolute risk of respiratory distress was 12.4 % for ECS (aRR:5.7; 95 %CI:4.8; 6.5) and 4.0 % for IOL (aRR:1.7; 95 %CI:1.5; 2.0). At 39 weeks, the absolute risk of respiratory distress for ECS was 3.2 % (aRR:1.6; 95 %CI:1.3; 1.8) whereas the risk was reduced for IOL. ECS <38 weeks increased the risk of Apgar <7 compared with EM.

Conclusion

Regarding neonatal respiratory distress, IOL was safe from 38 weeks and ECS from 40 weeks. At earlier gestational ages, the risk of respiratory distress was significantly higher, which highlights the importance of clear health policies regarding appropriate timing and indications for planned births by ECS and IOL.