Marek Wodzinski , Mateusz Daniol , Daria Hemmerling
{"title":"Automatic skull reconstruction by deep learnable symmetry enforcement","authors":"Marek Wodzinski , Mateusz Daniol , Daria Hemmerling","doi":"10.1016/j.cmpb.2025.108670","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<div><h3>Background and objective:</h3><div>Every year, thousands of people suffer from skull damage and require personalized implants to fill the cranial cavity. Unfortunately, the waiting time for reconstruction surgery can extend to several weeks or even months, especially in less developed countries. One factor contributing to the extended waiting period is the intricate process of personalized implant modeling. Currently, the preparation of these implants by experienced biomechanical experts is both costly and time-consuming. Recent advances in artificial intelligence, especially in deep learning, offer promising potential for automating the process. However, deep learning-based cranial reconstruction faces several challenges: (i) the limited size of training datasets, (ii) the high resolution of the volumetric data, and (iii) significant data heterogeneity.</div></div><div><h3>Methods:</h3><div>In this work, we propose a novel approach to address these challenges by enhancing the reconstruction through learnable symmetry enforcement. We demonstrate that it is possible to train a neural network dedicated to calculating skull symmetry, which can be utilized either as an additional objective function during training or as a post-reconstruction objective during the refinement step. We quantitatively evaluate the proposed method using open SkullBreak and SkullFix datasets, and qualitatively using real clinical cases.</div></div><div><h3>Results:</h3><div>The results indicate that the symmetry-preserving reconstruction network achieves considerably better outcomes compared to the baseline (0.94/0.94/1.31 vs 0.84/0.76/2.43 in terms of DSC, bDSC, and HD95). Moreover, the results are comparable to the best-performing methods while requiring significantly fewer computational resources (<span><math><mo><</mo></math></span> 500 vs <span><math><mo>></mo></math></span> 100,000 GPU hours). Moreover, its relatively low computational complexity makes it scalable for reconstructing all symmetrical structures.</div></div><div><h3>Conclusions:</h3><div>The article introduces an automatic skull reconstruction method based on the enforcement of skull symmetry using a learnable deep learning network. The method requires significantly fewer computational resources compared to other well-performing methods and is able to improve the reconstruction for the out-of-distribution cases. The proposed method is a considerable contribution to the field of applied artificial intelligence in medicine and is a step towards automatic cranial defect reconstruction in clinical practice.</div></div>","PeriodicalId":10624,"journal":{"name":"Computer methods and programs in biomedicine","volume":"263 ","pages":"Article 108670"},"PeriodicalIF":4.8000,"publicationDate":"2025-02-20","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Computer methods and programs in biomedicine","FirstCategoryId":"5","ListUrlMain":"https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0169260725000872","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"医学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"COMPUTER SCIENCE, INTERDISCIPLINARY APPLICATIONS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Background and objective:
Every year, thousands of people suffer from skull damage and require personalized implants to fill the cranial cavity. Unfortunately, the waiting time for reconstruction surgery can extend to several weeks or even months, especially in less developed countries. One factor contributing to the extended waiting period is the intricate process of personalized implant modeling. Currently, the preparation of these implants by experienced biomechanical experts is both costly and time-consuming. Recent advances in artificial intelligence, especially in deep learning, offer promising potential for automating the process. However, deep learning-based cranial reconstruction faces several challenges: (i) the limited size of training datasets, (ii) the high resolution of the volumetric data, and (iii) significant data heterogeneity.
Methods:
In this work, we propose a novel approach to address these challenges by enhancing the reconstruction through learnable symmetry enforcement. We demonstrate that it is possible to train a neural network dedicated to calculating skull symmetry, which can be utilized either as an additional objective function during training or as a post-reconstruction objective during the refinement step. We quantitatively evaluate the proposed method using open SkullBreak and SkullFix datasets, and qualitatively using real clinical cases.
Results:
The results indicate that the symmetry-preserving reconstruction network achieves considerably better outcomes compared to the baseline (0.94/0.94/1.31 vs 0.84/0.76/2.43 in terms of DSC, bDSC, and HD95). Moreover, the results are comparable to the best-performing methods while requiring significantly fewer computational resources ( 500 vs 100,000 GPU hours). Moreover, its relatively low computational complexity makes it scalable for reconstructing all symmetrical structures.
Conclusions:
The article introduces an automatic skull reconstruction method based on the enforcement of skull symmetry using a learnable deep learning network. The method requires significantly fewer computational resources compared to other well-performing methods and is able to improve the reconstruction for the out-of-distribution cases. The proposed method is a considerable contribution to the field of applied artificial intelligence in medicine and is a step towards automatic cranial defect reconstruction in clinical practice.
背景与目的:每年都有成千上万的人遭受颅骨损伤,需要个性化的植入物来填充颅腔。不幸的是,重建手术的等待时间可能会延长到几周甚至几个月,特别是在欠发达国家。导致等待时间延长的一个因素是个性化植入物建模的复杂过程。目前,由经验丰富的生物力学专家制备这些植入物既昂贵又耗时。人工智能的最新进展,特别是在深度学习方面,为这一过程的自动化提供了巨大的潜力。然而,基于深度学习的颅骨重建面临着几个挑战:(i)训练数据集的规模有限,(ii)体积数据的高分辨率,以及(iii)显著的数据异质性。方法:在这项工作中,我们提出了一种新的方法来解决这些挑战,即通过可学习的对称强制来增强重建。我们证明了训练一个专门用于计算头骨对称性的神经网络是可能的,它可以在训练期间用作附加目标函数,也可以在细化步骤期间用作重建后目标。我们使用开放的SkullBreak和SkullFix数据集对所提出的方法进行定量评估,并使用真实临床病例进行定性评估。结果:结果表明,与基线相比,对称保持重建网络取得了明显更好的结果(在DSC、bDSC和HD95方面分别为0.94/0.94/1.31和0.84/0.76/2.43)。此外,结果与性能最好的方法相当,同时需要的计算资源显著减少(<;500 vs >;100,000 GPU小时)。此外,其相对较低的计算复杂度使其可扩展到重建所有对称结构。结论:本文介绍了一种基于可学习深度学习网络增强颅骨对称性的自动颅骨重建方法。与其他性能良好的方法相比,该方法所需的计算资源显著减少,并且能够改善非分布情况下的重建。该方法对人工智能在医学领域的应用做出了重大贡献,是实现临床颅缺损自动重建的重要一步。
期刊介绍:
To encourage the development of formal computing methods, and their application in biomedical research and medical practice, by illustration of fundamental principles in biomedical informatics research; to stimulate basic research into application software design; to report the state of research of biomedical information processing projects; to report new computer methodologies applied in biomedical areas; the eventual distribution of demonstrable software to avoid duplication of effort; to provide a forum for discussion and improvement of existing software; to optimize contact between national organizations and regional user groups by promoting an international exchange of information on formal methods, standards and software in biomedicine.
Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine covers computing methodology and software systems derived from computing science for implementation in all aspects of biomedical research and medical practice. It is designed to serve: biochemists; biologists; geneticists; immunologists; neuroscientists; pharmacologists; toxicologists; clinicians; epidemiologists; psychiatrists; psychologists; cardiologists; chemists; (radio)physicists; computer scientists; programmers and systems analysts; biomedical, clinical, electrical and other engineers; teachers of medical informatics and users of educational software.