Evaluation of immune responses to inactivated influenza vaccines prepared in embryonated chicken eggs and MDCK cells in a mouse model.

Abstract

This study was initiated with the isolation of influenza A and B viruses from clinical throat swabs in both fertile chicken eggs (egg) and MDCK cells, which were used in subsequent vaccine production in the above two hosts. On the basis of haemagglutination-inhibiting (HI) tests, immune mouse sera from mice vaccinated with MDCK cell-derived vaccines revealed antigenic similarities among H3N2 or B viruses isolated in MDCK cells or eggs. Similarly, antiserum prepared by immunization with egg-derived H3N2 vaccine showed equivalent antigenicity between homologous and heterologous (MDCK cell-derived) viruses. In contrast, antigenicity of egg-derived B vaccines was differed somewhat from that of MDCK cell-derived vaccines, suggesting the occurrence of antigenic change due to passaging in eggs. The time-course of immune responses based on HI titres indicated that MDCK cell-derived vaccines elicited extremely high antibody levels. Also, it was evident that antibody production by MDCK cell-grown H3N2 vaccine was very similar to that of vaccine prepared from egg-grown viruses. These results were comparable to those of plaque neutralization tests, although antigenic differences between egg- and MDCK cell-derived challenge viruses were confirmed in the test with antiserum to MDCK cell-derived vaccine. Consistent with HI-antibody production, the immunogenicity of MDCK cell-derived B vaccine appeared to be low by plaque neutralization test, while immune responses in mice which received egg-derived vaccines were significantly higher than that of the former. Furthermore, immune responses confirmed in mice immunized with B virus vaccines prepared in eggs revealed slight antigenic differences between two viruses derived from their respective hosts. Nevertheless, through evaluation of immune responses, MDCK cell-derived influenza vaccines may be useful when weak immunogenicity of B virus vaccine is improved.