Exact median-tree inference for unrooted reconciliation costs.

Abstract

Background: Solving median tree problems under tree reconciliation costs is a classic and well-studied approach for inferring species trees from collections of discordant gene trees. These problems are NP-hard, and therefore are, in practice, typically addressed by local search heuristics. So far, however, such heuristics lack any provable correctness or precision. Further, even for small phylogenetic studies, it has been demonstrated that local search heuristics may only provide sub-optimal solutions. Obviating such heuristic uncertainties are exact dynamic programming solutions that allow solving tree reconciliation problems for smaller phylogenetic studies. Despite these promises, such exact solutions are only suitable for credibly rooted input gene trees, which constitute only a tiny fraction of the readily available gene trees. Standard gene tree inference approaches provide only unrooted gene trees and accurately rooting such trees is often difficult, if not impossible.

Results: Here, we describe complex dynamic programming solutions that represent the first nonnaïve exact solutions for solving the tree reconciliation problems for unrooted input gene trees. Further, we show that the asymptotic runtime of the proposed solutions does not increase when compared to the most time-efficient dynamic programming solutions for rooted input trees.

Conclusions: In an experimental evaluation, we demonstrate that the described solutions for unrooted gene trees are, like the solutions for rooted input gene trees, suitable for smaller phylogenetic studies. Finally, for the first time, we study the accuracy of classic local search heuristics for unrooted tree reconciliation problems.