Comparison of ECG Baseline Wander Removal Techniques and Improvement Based on Moving Average of Wavelet Approximation Coefficients

Abstract

The baseline wander is among the artifacts that corrupt the ECG signal. This noise can affect some signal features, in particular the ST segment, which is an important marker for the diagnosis of ischemia. This paper presents a study on the effectiveness of several methods and techniques for suppressing the baseline wonder (BW) from the ECG signals. As a result, a new technique called moving average of wavelet approximation coefficients (DWT-MAV) is proposed. The techniques concerned are the moving average, the approximation of the baseline by polynomial fitting, the Savitzky-Golay filtering, and the discrete wavelet transform (DWT). The comparison of this techniques is performed using the main criteria for assessing the BW denoising quality criteria such mean square error (MSE), percent root mean square difference (PRD) and correlation coefficient (COR). In this paper, three other criteria of comparison are proposed namely the number of samples of the ECG signal, the baseline frequency variation and the time processing. Two of these new indices are related to possible real time ECG denoising. To improve the quality of BW suppression including the new indices, a new method is proposed. This technique is a combination of the DWT and the moving average methods. This new technique performs the best compromise in terms of MSE, PRD, coefficient correlation and the time processing. The simulations were performed on ECG recording from MIT-BIH database with synthetic and real baselines.