{"title":"Indicating hours in ancient cultures","authors":"Annette Imhausen","doi":"10.1177/00218286211043958","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"For the most part, these inquiries, though substantive and valuable, are narrow. They comprise more of a gathering of specialist inquiries than a synthesis of varied material and fundamental principles. This remains evident in Aveni’s very useful concluding commentary. He highlights interesting elements of the articles but is hard-pressed to identify a singular, unifying perspective from their content. Documentation and formalization of research are among the primary functions of academic publication, and this assembly of work on the measure and meaning of time in Mesoamerica and the Andes addresses those tasks. The value of each article for each reader will vary with the reader’s specialized interest and knowledge. The articles range from the highly abstract to the unambiguously concrete. For example, “Ecumene Time, Anecume Time: Proposal and Paradigm” by Alfredo López Austin systematizes most of the fundamentals of Aztec cosmovision and mythic creation in a framework that distinguishes between time of this world and time not of this world. More tangible cultural assets are examined by Stella Nair in “Space and Time in the Architecture of Inca Royal Estates.” Although I’m not convinced the Inca ruler deliberately manipulated architecture and landscape on behalf of an intended perception of time, the hierarchy of power is evident in this deliciously specific analysis of the king’s design of royal estates. Other topics include time and animate objects for contemporary Tz’utujil Maya ritualists, Classic Maya concepts of time and space, the ceque system of Cuzco, time and the Huarochiri Manuscript, linearity and cyclicity in Maya calendrics, calendrical considerations in Mexican dynastic imagery, world ages in the Andes, time and political emblems in Colonial Peru, and calendars and computers in Mesoamerica and Bali. This is a rich inventory, but it is intended for those working seriously in Mesoamerican and Andean archaeology and anthropology and with interests related to the authors’ priorities. Readers need to come already equipped with the basics and the motivation to penetrate esoteric material. Anyone believing the end of the world was upon us in 2012 and looking for superficial guidance would have been made impatient for the Apocalypse by the intellectual investment this book requires.","PeriodicalId":56280,"journal":{"name":"Journal for the History of Astronomy","volume":"53 1","pages":"125 - 127"},"PeriodicalIF":0.3000,"publicationDate":"2022-02-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal for the History of Astronomy","FirstCategoryId":"98","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1177/00218286211043958","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"哲学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"HISTORY & PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
For the most part, these inquiries, though substantive and valuable, are narrow. They comprise more of a gathering of specialist inquiries than a synthesis of varied material and fundamental principles. This remains evident in Aveni’s very useful concluding commentary. He highlights interesting elements of the articles but is hard-pressed to identify a singular, unifying perspective from their content. Documentation and formalization of research are among the primary functions of academic publication, and this assembly of work on the measure and meaning of time in Mesoamerica and the Andes addresses those tasks. The value of each article for each reader will vary with the reader’s specialized interest and knowledge. The articles range from the highly abstract to the unambiguously concrete. For example, “Ecumene Time, Anecume Time: Proposal and Paradigm” by Alfredo López Austin systematizes most of the fundamentals of Aztec cosmovision and mythic creation in a framework that distinguishes between time of this world and time not of this world. More tangible cultural assets are examined by Stella Nair in “Space and Time in the Architecture of Inca Royal Estates.” Although I’m not convinced the Inca ruler deliberately manipulated architecture and landscape on behalf of an intended perception of time, the hierarchy of power is evident in this deliciously specific analysis of the king’s design of royal estates. Other topics include time and animate objects for contemporary Tz’utujil Maya ritualists, Classic Maya concepts of time and space, the ceque system of Cuzco, time and the Huarochiri Manuscript, linearity and cyclicity in Maya calendrics, calendrical considerations in Mexican dynastic imagery, world ages in the Andes, time and political emblems in Colonial Peru, and calendars and computers in Mesoamerica and Bali. This is a rich inventory, but it is intended for those working seriously in Mesoamerican and Andean archaeology and anthropology and with interests related to the authors’ priorities. Readers need to come already equipped with the basics and the motivation to penetrate esoteric material. Anyone believing the end of the world was upon us in 2012 and looking for superficial guidance would have been made impatient for the Apocalypse by the intellectual investment this book requires.
在大多数情况下,这些调查,虽然实质性和有价值,是狭隘的。它们更多的是专家调查的集合,而不是各种材料和基本原理的综合。这在阿韦尼非常有用的结束语中仍然很明显。他强调了文章中有趣的元素,但很难从内容中找到一个单一的、统一的视角。学术出版物的主要功能是记录和正式研究,而这本关于中美洲和安第斯山脉时间测量和意义的著作集就是为了完成这些任务。每篇文章对每个读者的价值将随着读者的专业兴趣和知识而变化。文章的范围从高度抽象到明确具体。例如,Alfredo López Austin的“Ecumene Time, Anecume Time: Proposal and Paradigm”将阿兹特克宇宙观和神话创造的大部分基本原理系统化,在一个框架中区分了这个世界的时间和不是这个世界的时间。斯特拉·奈尔(Stella Nair)在《印加皇家庄园建筑中的空间与时间》(Space and Time in Architecture of印加皇家庄园)一书中考察了更多的有形文化资产。虽然我不相信印加统治者故意操纵建筑和景观,以代表一种有意的时间观念,但在对国王设计的皇家庄园的美味具体分析中,权力的等级制度是显而易见的。其他主题包括当代Tz 'utujil玛雅仪式主义者的时间和动画对象,经典的玛雅时间和空间概念,库斯科的顺序系统,时间和Huarochiri手稿,玛雅历法的线性和循环性,墨西哥王朝图像中的历法考虑,安第斯山脉的世界时代,秘鲁殖民地的时间和政治象征,中美洲和巴厘岛的日历和计算机。这是一份丰富的清单,但它是为那些认真研究中美洲和安第斯考古学和人类学的人准备的,并且对作者的优先事项感兴趣。读者需要具备基本的知识和动机来阅读深奥的材料。任何相信世界末日将在2012年降临的人,只要寻找肤浅的指引,就会因为这本书所要求的智力投入而对《启示录》失去耐心。
期刊介绍:
Science History Publications Ltd is an academic publishing company established in 1971 and based in Cambridge, England. We specialize in journals in history of science and in particular history of astronomy.