„PUTOVATI I STALNO POMERATI CILj“: NEMAČKA I SRPSKI DRŽAVNI NARATIV O EVRO-INTEGRACIJAMA

Q3 Arts and Humanities Komunikacija i Kultura Online Pub Date : 2018-12-08 DOI:10.18485/kkonline.2018.9.9.7
Ana Jovanovic
{"title":"„PUTOVATI I STALNO POMERATI CILj“: NEMAČKA I SRPSKI DRŽAVNI NARATIV O EVRO-INTEGRACIJAMA","authors":"Ana Jovanovic","doi":"10.18485/kkonline.2018.9.9.7","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"European integration process has been one of the dominant topics in Serbian political agenda ever since the regime-change and the restoration of democracy in 2000. Social and economic reforms related to that process are metaphorically represented in Serbian political and public discourse as the “European path” of Serbia. It is a variant of the “Path to Democracy” metaphor and the idea behind it is the assumption that democracy is the most moral form of government (Lakoff 1999). The EU and its political, social and economic system are presented as the best model for the future of Serbia and the EU influence is openly accepted by the Serbian political elite as an integral part of policy-making process (Stojic 2006). Since this complex political, social and economic transition, commonly referred to as “reforms” in political and public discourse, often implies painful changes for different groups of Serbian society, it is important to present it not only as a desirable and necessary but also as an inevitable process. This is accomplished by a careful choice of argumentative tools that the Serbian political elite apply to discursively construct the Serbian Euro-integration process (“the European path” of Serbia). This discourse is an important part of Serbian state narrative, since it explains relations with other states and determines directions of definition for both internal and external politics. Because state narratives are an effective tool for spreading state ideologies, it is important to analyze them in order to better understand the political discourse and the actions it motivates within a society. Therefore, I build on existing scholarship on two important elements of Serbian state narrative on the European integration process, the conceptual metaphor and the cognitive frame, to examine ways in which this narrative is used by political actors to promote their political agenda, namely, the social, political and economic reforms Serbia is obliged to carry out in order to join the EU. Special attention is dedicated to the new framing of Germany, presented and perceived in public as a state with the crucial role for the success of Serbian “European path”. The corpus is composed of statements of the current president of Serbia, Aleksandar Vucic, and media reports on his activities, covering the topic of European integration process and the role of Germany in it. This particular corpus is chosen because of the prominent role Aleksandar Vucic has played in Serbian politics in the last several years, serving the most important political functions of Deputy Prime Minister, Prime Minister and President-elect, which makes him currently the key policy-maker in Serbia. The chronological span of the corpus is the period from the rise of this politician to power in 2012 till 2017, when he became President-elect of Serbia. My analysis shows that this political actor: a) metaphorically constructs the European integration process as the “European path of Serbia”; b) presents Serbian-German relations through new cognitive frames, by strategically using the traditional Serbian narrative on Germans and their states. In doing so, he deactivates the well-established frame of aggression and threat posed by the Germans and activates the equally rooted frame of Germans as disciplined and hard-working people. Using the metaphor “Nation/ State is a Person”, where national mentalities correspond to personal characteristics of an individual, Vucic emphasizes positive characteristics of German mentality as the model that Serbs should look upon in order to be successful in their “European path”. The objective of this frame change is to further promote and justify the social, political and economic reforms carried out in the transition process of Serbia, since these reforms often prove to be harmful for numerous groups in the Serbian society (the so called “victims of transition”). \nThe structure of the paper is as follows: I first present the key theoretical concepts (state narrative, conceptual metaphor and cognitive frame) and then apply them to the qualitative analysis of the corpus. Certain discursive patterns have been observed both in Vucic’s statements and the media coverage of his activities. Relaying on theoretical framework based on postulates of cognitive linguistics and critical discourse analysis (which is interested in the ways language/ discourse contributes to the dynamics of power relations within a society), I offer possible explanations of meanings and functions of the observed discursive patterns. The results of the analysis confirm the importance of the strategic use of state narratives in political discourse as a part of the process of creation of new meanings and promotion of political agendas.","PeriodicalId":37164,"journal":{"name":"Komunikacija i Kultura Online","volume":"9 1","pages":"119-140"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2018-12-08","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Komunikacija i Kultura Online","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.18485/kkonline.2018.9.9.7","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q3","JCRName":"Arts and Humanities","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

Abstract

European integration process has been one of the dominant topics in Serbian political agenda ever since the regime-change and the restoration of democracy in 2000. Social and economic reforms related to that process are metaphorically represented in Serbian political and public discourse as the “European path” of Serbia. It is a variant of the “Path to Democracy” metaphor and the idea behind it is the assumption that democracy is the most moral form of government (Lakoff 1999). The EU and its political, social and economic system are presented as the best model for the future of Serbia and the EU influence is openly accepted by the Serbian political elite as an integral part of policy-making process (Stojic 2006). Since this complex political, social and economic transition, commonly referred to as “reforms” in political and public discourse, often implies painful changes for different groups of Serbian society, it is important to present it not only as a desirable and necessary but also as an inevitable process. This is accomplished by a careful choice of argumentative tools that the Serbian political elite apply to discursively construct the Serbian Euro-integration process (“the European path” of Serbia). This discourse is an important part of Serbian state narrative, since it explains relations with other states and determines directions of definition for both internal and external politics. Because state narratives are an effective tool for spreading state ideologies, it is important to analyze them in order to better understand the political discourse and the actions it motivates within a society. Therefore, I build on existing scholarship on two important elements of Serbian state narrative on the European integration process, the conceptual metaphor and the cognitive frame, to examine ways in which this narrative is used by political actors to promote their political agenda, namely, the social, political and economic reforms Serbia is obliged to carry out in order to join the EU. Special attention is dedicated to the new framing of Germany, presented and perceived in public as a state with the crucial role for the success of Serbian “European path”. The corpus is composed of statements of the current president of Serbia, Aleksandar Vucic, and media reports on his activities, covering the topic of European integration process and the role of Germany in it. This particular corpus is chosen because of the prominent role Aleksandar Vucic has played in Serbian politics in the last several years, serving the most important political functions of Deputy Prime Minister, Prime Minister and President-elect, which makes him currently the key policy-maker in Serbia. The chronological span of the corpus is the period from the rise of this politician to power in 2012 till 2017, when he became President-elect of Serbia. My analysis shows that this political actor: a) metaphorically constructs the European integration process as the “European path of Serbia”; b) presents Serbian-German relations through new cognitive frames, by strategically using the traditional Serbian narrative on Germans and their states. In doing so, he deactivates the well-established frame of aggression and threat posed by the Germans and activates the equally rooted frame of Germans as disciplined and hard-working people. Using the metaphor “Nation/ State is a Person”, where national mentalities correspond to personal characteristics of an individual, Vucic emphasizes positive characteristics of German mentality as the model that Serbs should look upon in order to be successful in their “European path”. The objective of this frame change is to further promote and justify the social, political and economic reforms carried out in the transition process of Serbia, since these reforms often prove to be harmful for numerous groups in the Serbian society (the so called “victims of transition”). The structure of the paper is as follows: I first present the key theoretical concepts (state narrative, conceptual metaphor and cognitive frame) and then apply them to the qualitative analysis of the corpus. Certain discursive patterns have been observed both in Vucic’s statements and the media coverage of his activities. Relaying on theoretical framework based on postulates of cognitive linguistics and critical discourse analysis (which is interested in the ways language/ discourse contributes to the dynamics of power relations within a society), I offer possible explanations of meanings and functions of the observed discursive patterns. The results of the analysis confirm the importance of the strategic use of state narratives in political discourse as a part of the process of creation of new meanings and promotion of political agendas.
查看原文
分享 分享
微信好友 朋友圈 QQ好友 复制链接
本刊更多论文
“旅行并不断移动目标”:德国和塞尔维亚关于EVRO-INTEGRATION的国家法律
自2000年政权更迭和恢复民主以来,欧洲一体化进程一直是塞尔维亚政治议程上的主导议题之一。与这一进程有关的社会和经济改革在塞尔维亚的政治和公共话语中被比喻为塞尔维亚的“欧洲道路”。这是“民主之路”隐喻的变体,其背后的理念是假设民主是最道德的政府形式(Lakoff 1999)。欧盟及其政治、社会和经济体系被认为是塞尔维亚未来的最佳模式,欧盟的影响力被塞尔维亚政治精英公开接受为决策过程的一个组成部分(Stojic 2006)。由于这种复杂的政治、社会和经济转型,在政治和公共话语中通常被称为“改革”,往往意味着塞尔维亚社会不同群体的痛苦变化,因此重要的是,不仅要将其视为一个可取和必要的过程,而且要将其作为一个不可避免的过程。这是通过仔细选择塞尔维亚政治精英用来讨论构建塞尔维亚-欧洲一体化进程(塞尔维亚的“欧洲道路”)的辩论工具来实现的。这种话语是塞尔维亚国家叙事的重要组成部分,因为它解释了与其他国家的关系,并确定了内部和外部政治的定义方向。由于国家叙事是传播国家意识形态的有效工具,因此分析它们以更好地理解政治话语及其在社会中激励的行动是很重要的。因此,我在现有关于塞尔维亚国家叙事中关于欧洲一体化进程的两个重要元素的学术基础上,即概念隐喻和认知框架,来研究政治行为者如何利用这种叙事来推动其政治议程,即塞尔维亚为加入欧盟而必须进行的社会、政治和经济改革。特别关注德国的新框架,该框架在公众面前被呈现和视为对塞尔维亚“欧洲道路”的成功具有关键作用的国家。该语料库由塞尔维亚现任总统亚历山大·武契奇的声明和媒体对其活动的报道组成,涵盖了欧洲一体化进程和德国在其中的作用。之所以选择该语料库,是因为亚历山大·武西奇在过去几年中在塞尔维亚政治中发挥了突出作用,担任副总理、总理和当选总统等最重要的政治职务,这使他目前成为塞尔维亚的主要决策者。语料库的时间跨度是从这位政治家2012年上台到2017年成为塞尔维亚当选总统的这段时间。我的分析表明,这个政治行动者:a)隐喻性地将欧洲一体化进程构建为“塞尔维亚的欧洲道路”;b) 通过新的认知框架,战略性地使用塞尔维亚人对德国人及其国家的传统叙事,呈现塞尔维亚与德国的关系。在这样做的过程中,他停用了德国人构成的侵略和威胁的既定框架,并激活了德国人作为有纪律和勤奋的人的同样根深蒂固的框架。武契奇用“民族/国家是一个人”这个比喻,即民族心态与个人的个人特征相对应,强调德国心态的积极特征是塞尔维亚人在“欧洲道路”上取得成功所应该关注的模式。这一框架变化的目的是进一步促进和证明在塞尔维亚过渡进程中进行的社会、政治和经济改革是合理的,因为这些改革往往对塞尔维亚社会中的许多群体(所谓的“过渡受害者”)有害。本文的结构如下:首先提出了关键的理论概念(状态叙事、概念隐喻和认知框架),然后将其应用于语料库的定性分析。在武契奇的声明和媒体对其活动的报道中都观察到了某些话语模式。基于认知语言学和批判性话语分析(对语言/话语如何促进社会内部权力关系的动态感兴趣)的假设,我对所观察到的话语模式的含义和功能提供了可能的解释。分析结果证实了在政治话语中战略性地使用国家叙事作为创造新意义和促进政治议程过程的一部分的重要性。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 去求助
来源期刊
Komunikacija i Kultura Online
Komunikacija i Kultura Online Arts and Humanities-Literature and Literary Theory
CiteScore
0.20
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
审稿时长
8 weeks
期刊最新文献
The Place of American English in European Education Virna Karlić i Petra Bago, (Računalna) pragmatika. Temeljni pojmovi i korpusnopragmatičke analize. Zagreb: Sveučilište u Zagrebu „Ff-Press”, 2021, 275 str. Mark Twain and the United Kingdom: A Peculiar Relationship? It’s Like Being Hit by a Tsunami: The use of the natural force Metaphor for Conceptualising the COVID-19 Pandemic in English and Serbian Online Mode of Autobiographical Reminiscing: Discourse Practices in Digital Society
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
现在去查看 取消
×
提示
确定
0
微信
客服QQ
Book学术公众号 扫码关注我们
反馈
×
意见反馈
请填写您的意见或建议
请填写您的手机或邮箱
已复制链接
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
×
扫码分享
扫码分享
Book学术官方微信
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术
文献互助 智能选刊 最新文献 互助须知 联系我们:info@booksci.cn
Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。
Copyright © 2023 Book学术 All rights reserved.
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号 京ICP备2023020795号-1