Native fish abundance and habitat selection changes in the presence of nonnative piscivores

Abstract

We compared abundance patterns and developed resource selection models for imperilled native southwestern (USA) fishes in the presence and absence of Black Bass (Micropterus spp.) to evaluate how fishes alter their selection for habitats when sympatric with a nonnative piscivore. We collected data using snorkel surveys and in-stream habitat sampling in Fossil Creek (AZ), upstream (native fish only) and downstream (native and nonnative fish) of a fish barrier. The abundance of all Roundtail Chub (Gila robusta), small (≤127 mm total length [TL]; vulnerable to predation) Sonora Sucker (Catostomus insignis) and Speckled Dace (Rhinichthys osculus) was significantly reduced, but the abundance of both small and large (>127 mm TL; invulnerable to predation) Desert Sucker (Catostomus clarkii) was similar in sampling reaches with and without Black Bass. When sympatric with Black Bass, small Roundtail Chub increased their selection for riffles by 2.57 times and small Desert Sucker reduce their selection for pools by 6.90 times while also selecting for faster flow velocity and finer substrates in lotic mesohabitats. Large native fishes altered selection least, notwithstanding an increased selection for canopy cover in sampling reaches with Black Bass. Observed shifts in resource selection are consistent with predator avoidance strategies. Our study highlights the behavioural consequences of nonnative piscivores on native fish communities and stresses the importance of maintaining lotic mesohabitats as potential refugia for vulnerable native fishes when nonnative piscivores are present.