Beyond the walls of Camden & Islington personality disorder service: a qualitative study of clinical consultation to external services

Abstract

The Camden and Islington Personality Disorder Service (PDS) increasingly provides clinical consultation to external services. There is a dearth of research on the experience of clinicians delivering such consultation. Interviews were conducted with clinicians from the PDS, and a semantic Thematic Analysis was conducted on transcripts to answer the question, ‘What is the experience of Personality Disorder Service staff providing input to staff in external services?’ 13 sub-themes under four overarching themes were identified (these latter were: Anxiety, Fragmented Co-working, Task Difficulty, and Positive Outcome). These themes provide an overview of the experience of consulting clinicians. Themes are explored through Kleinian psychoanalytic theory, with reference to Bion’s work on containment and groups. Findings suggest that staff need to retain thinking space to work effectively, to feel safe and recover a sense of competence when it is attacked, highlighting the need for access to structures such as supervision. The responsibility for trying to reduce distress, risk (to self, to and from others) and functional disability of people with a diagnosis of personality disorder cannot belong to one person or service but services need to be able to think together to gain a better understanding and have an agreed cross-service response.