Retrospective Cohort Study on the Surgical Outcomes of Intracapsular Thyroidectomy Vs Standard Thyroidectomy.

Abstract

The focal point of thyroidectomy surgery has always been to reduce the incidence of inadvertent damage to the recurrent laryngeal nerve(RLN). The intracapsular thyroidectomy is one such technique with minimum chance of injuring the nerve. To compare retrospectively the surgical outcomes between the two methods of thyroidectomy-coventional thyroidectomy Vs intracapsular thyroidectomy. Materials and methods-55 cases of benign thyroid disease for whom thyroidectomy was performed in our hospital between the period of 2019-2022 were compared retrospectively. Out of these 34 cases had undergone intracapsular thyroidectomy and 21 cases underwent routine extracapsular thyroidectomy. The surgical outcomes including operation time, pain, postoperative infection, postoperative hypocalcemia, postoperative recurrent laryngeal nerve paralysis and mean hospital stay were analyzed. The mean operating time were very low in the intracapsular limb as compared to the other group. The pain and the mean hospital stay was also far lesser for the intracapsular limb. Both cohorts had no incidence of hypocalcemia. The incidence of recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy was very low in the intracapsular cohort (only 1 case of temporary unilateral RLN palsy), whereas it was higher in the routine extracapsular cohort (5 cases of permanent palsy). The risk of having vocal cord palsy (left/right) is 1.172 times more with conventional/standard thyroidectomy as compared to intracapsular thyroidectomy. Intracapsular technique is a much more rewarding method to perform thyroidectomy, without the risk of the recurrent laryngeal nerve palsy as compared to routine thyroidectomy.