{"title":"Women and healthcare in early modern German towns","authors":"A. Kinzelbach","doi":"10.1111/rest.12082","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"This article is a study of women's continued involvement in healthcare practice in German Imperial towns and cities between the fifteenth century and the mid eighteenth century. It contextualizes the defamatory rhetoric against women healers found in printed books and publications, corrects the distortions of juridical administrative sources, and modifies the frequent complaints of medical corporations. Comparing the sources produced by hospital administrators and by other administrative agencies with the practice notes of a physician allows us to see women's day‐to‐day medical tasks in institutions and households, their shared competencies and networks, as well as their role in facilitating the flow of medical information. Moreover, female practitioners belonging to different social and cultural strata, who fulfilled varying levels of medical tasks, become visible by analysing institutional sources in conjunction with more private records documenting the intersection of domestic healthcare with treatment offered by certified practitioners. Contrary to what administrative and hospital records suggest, the handwritten daily notes of the Nuremberg physician Johann Christoph Götz do not indicate a devaluation of female medical expertise in the early modern period; on the contrary, the information of learned women from mercantile or academic families became part of the process by which medical knowledge was created.","PeriodicalId":45351,"journal":{"name":"Renaissance Studies","volume":"8 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.3000,"publicationDate":"2014-09-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"85","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Renaissance Studies","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1111/rest.12082","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"历史学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"MEDIEVAL & RENAISSANCE STUDIES","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 85
Abstract
This article is a study of women's continued involvement in healthcare practice in German Imperial towns and cities between the fifteenth century and the mid eighteenth century. It contextualizes the defamatory rhetoric against women healers found in printed books and publications, corrects the distortions of juridical administrative sources, and modifies the frequent complaints of medical corporations. Comparing the sources produced by hospital administrators and by other administrative agencies with the practice notes of a physician allows us to see women's day‐to‐day medical tasks in institutions and households, their shared competencies and networks, as well as their role in facilitating the flow of medical information. Moreover, female practitioners belonging to different social and cultural strata, who fulfilled varying levels of medical tasks, become visible by analysing institutional sources in conjunction with more private records documenting the intersection of domestic healthcare with treatment offered by certified practitioners. Contrary to what administrative and hospital records suggest, the handwritten daily notes of the Nuremberg physician Johann Christoph Götz do not indicate a devaluation of female medical expertise in the early modern period; on the contrary, the information of learned women from mercantile or academic families became part of the process by which medical knowledge was created.
这篇文章是对15世纪到18世纪中期德国帝国城镇中妇女持续参与医疗保健实践的研究。它将印刷书籍和出版物中对女治疗师的诽谤言论置于背景之下,纠正了司法行政来源的歪曲,并修改了医疗公司的频繁投诉。将医院管理人员和其他行政机构提供的资料与医生的执业记录进行比较,可以让我们看到妇女在机构和家庭中的日常医疗任务,她们共同的能力和网络,以及她们在促进医疗信息流动方面的作用。此外,来自不同社会和文化阶层的女性从业人员完成了不同程度的医疗任务,通过分析机构来源,并结合记录家庭保健与认证从业人员提供的治疗的更多私人记录,可以看到这些女性从业人员。与行政和医院记录所显示的相反,纽伦堡医生Johann Christoph Götz的手写日常笔记并不表明女性医疗专业知识在现代早期贬值;相反,来自商人或学者家庭的有学问的妇女的信息成为创造医学知识过程的一部分。
期刊介绍:
Renaissance Studies is a multi-disciplinary journal which publishes articles and editions of documents on all aspects of Renaissance history and culture. The articles range over the history, art, architecture, religion, literature, and languages of Europe during the period.