Shakinah Ravindran, S. Saufi, Wan Nur Amni, I. Ishak, N. H. Hamid, C. Abidin, A. H. Ahmad, G. Azzam, Hasber Salim
{"title":"Sex identification comparison of barn owls (Tyto alba javanica) using morphological features and molecular-based methods","authors":"Shakinah Ravindran, S. Saufi, Wan Nur Amni, I. Ishak, N. H. Hamid, C. Abidin, A. H. Ahmad, G. Azzam, Hasber Salim","doi":"10.2478/srj-2018-0005","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Abstract Sexing of barn owls, Tyto alba javanica, using morphological traits has not been accurate enough due to ambiguous sexual dimorphism between sexes. This has been one of the major problems for the management of barn owls worldwide, especially for translocation and captive-breeding programs. In order to increase the success rate of sexing the barn owl, we compared the results of a molecular sexing method to six morphological traits for sexing the owls: the shape and colour of the facial disc, the colour of the throat area, the tail plumage, the colour of their tarsus, the back plumage, and the frequency of spotting on the chest and underside of the wings. The result of our comparison showed that sex identification using morphological traits had an accuracy of only 72.7%. Three of our samples were identified as females using morphological traits, but molecular sexing determined that these samples were males. We also used our results to determine the best morphological traits for sexing barn owls, and concluded that the best traits for morphological sexing are the frequency of spotting on the chest and underparts of barn owls (accuracy of 81.8%), as well as colour of the owls’ facial disc and throat area (accuracy of 63.6%).","PeriodicalId":56343,"journal":{"name":"Slovak Raptor Journal","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2018-12-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"4","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Slovak Raptor Journal","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2478/srj-2018-0005","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 4
Abstract
Abstract Sexing of barn owls, Tyto alba javanica, using morphological traits has not been accurate enough due to ambiguous sexual dimorphism between sexes. This has been one of the major problems for the management of barn owls worldwide, especially for translocation and captive-breeding programs. In order to increase the success rate of sexing the barn owl, we compared the results of a molecular sexing method to six morphological traits for sexing the owls: the shape and colour of the facial disc, the colour of the throat area, the tail plumage, the colour of their tarsus, the back plumage, and the frequency of spotting on the chest and underside of the wings. The result of our comparison showed that sex identification using morphological traits had an accuracy of only 72.7%. Three of our samples were identified as females using morphological traits, but molecular sexing determined that these samples were males. We also used our results to determine the best morphological traits for sexing barn owls, and concluded that the best traits for morphological sexing are the frequency of spotting on the chest and underparts of barn owls (accuracy of 81.8%), as well as colour of the owls’ facial disc and throat area (accuracy of 63.6%).
摘要仓鸮(Tyto alba javanica)性别二态性不明确,利用形态学特征进行性别鉴定不够准确。这一直是全球仓鸮管理的主要问题之一,特别是在转移和圈养繁殖计划中。为了提高仓鸮的性别鉴定成功率,我们将分子性别鉴定方法的结果与6个用于猫头鹰性别鉴定的形态学特征进行了比较:面盘的形状和颜色、喉咙区域的颜色、尾羽、跗关节的颜色、背部羽毛以及胸部和翅膀下的斑点频率。比较结果表明,利用形态特征进行性别鉴定的准确率仅为72.7%。我们的三个样本通过形态学特征被确定为雌性,但分子性别鉴定确定这些样本是雄性。我们还利用我们的结果确定了仓鸮的最佳形态特征,得出仓鸮的最佳形态特征是胸部和腹部斑点的频率(准确率为81.8%),以及仓鸮的面盘和喉咙区域的颜色(准确率为63.6%)。
期刊介绍:
Journal for science, research and conservation on birds of prey and owls. Slovak Raptor Journal is issued generally annually and publishes original papers, reviews, short notes and other articles focusing on birds of prey and owls. All articles are published in English.