La tabula censualis de Pelóu (Grandas de Salime, Asturias: HEp 18, 2009, 21) en el marco del Noroeste hispano: un ensayo de definición como documento de gestión militar
{"title":"La tabula censualis de Pelóu (Grandas de Salime, Asturias: HEp 18, 2009, 21) en el marco del Noroeste hispano: un ensayo de definición como documento de gestión militar","authors":"A. Rodríguez Fernández","doi":"10.3989/aespa.093.020.009","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"espanolEl curso de las excavaciones de 2003-2006 en el castro conocido como “Monte Castrelo” de Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias) tuvo entre otros sorprendentes hallazgos epigraficos una inscripcion que ha sido considerada una posible tabula censualis. Se trata de una lista de unos cincuenta individuos inscrita en pizarra, material comun del contexto geologico de la region occidental asturiana. A pesar de su importancia apenas ha recibido un tratamiento monografico y, en general, ha tendido a admitirse su naturaleza oficial de censo. A partir de las observaciones y reservas argumentadas recientemente por Lopez Barja sobre lo inapropiado de concederle un valor censual de este tipo, el analisis del paisaje y el metodo comparativo con otras listas abren nuevos caminos de cara a una mejor definicion de la naturaleza del documento. EnglishDuring the archaeological fieldwork campaigns of 2003- 2006, in the so-called “Monte Castrelo” of Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias), a Roman inscription was found among other surprising findings. It was initially considered a tabula censualis. The inscription is a list of about fifty individuals written down on a slate, a very common material in the western part of Asturias. Despite its significance, it still has not received a monographic study, so its official nature has been generally admitted as a part of provincial census. After the recent comments and observations made by Lopez Barja on this point, who defends that a census function is innapropriate in this case, we can approach the issue through landscape perspectives and a comparative method with other informal lists, which can forge new paths for a better understanding of this document.","PeriodicalId":8356,"journal":{"name":"Archivo Espanol De Arqueologia","volume":"1 1","pages":"183-199"},"PeriodicalIF":0.1000,"publicationDate":"2020-09-08","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Archivo Espanol De Arqueologia","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.3989/aespa.093.020.009","RegionNum":3,"RegionCategory":"历史学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"0","JCRName":"ARCHAEOLOGY","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
espanolEl curso de las excavaciones de 2003-2006 en el castro conocido como “Monte Castrelo” de Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias) tuvo entre otros sorprendentes hallazgos epigraficos una inscripcion que ha sido considerada una posible tabula censualis. Se trata de una lista de unos cincuenta individuos inscrita en pizarra, material comun del contexto geologico de la region occidental asturiana. A pesar de su importancia apenas ha recibido un tratamiento monografico y, en general, ha tendido a admitirse su naturaleza oficial de censo. A partir de las observaciones y reservas argumentadas recientemente por Lopez Barja sobre lo inapropiado de concederle un valor censual de este tipo, el analisis del paisaje y el metodo comparativo con otras listas abren nuevos caminos de cara a una mejor definicion de la naturaleza del documento. EnglishDuring the archaeological fieldwork campaigns of 2003- 2006, in the so-called “Monte Castrelo” of Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias), a Roman inscription was found among other surprising findings. It was initially considered a tabula censualis. The inscription is a list of about fifty individuals written down on a slate, a very common material in the western part of Asturias. Despite its significance, it still has not received a monographic study, so its official nature has been generally admitted as a part of provincial census. After the recent comments and observations made by Lopez Barja on this point, who defends that a census function is innapropriate in this case, we can approach the issue through landscape perspectives and a comparative method with other informal lists, which can forge new paths for a better understanding of this document.
pelou的censualis tabula (Grandas de Salime, Asturias: HEp 18, 2009, 21)在西班牙西北部的背景下:作为军事管理文件的定义测试
在2003-2006年对Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias)被称为“Monte Castrelo”的卡斯特罗的挖掘过程中,在其他令人惊讶的碑文发现中,有一段铭文被认为是可能的人口普查表。这是一份刻在石板上的大约50人的名单,石板是西阿斯图里亚地区地质背景的常见材料。尽管它很重要,但它几乎没有得到专论的处理,一般来说,它的官方人口普查性质往往得到承认。根据Lopez Barja最近的观察和保留意见,给予这种类型的人口普查价值是不合适的,景观分析和与其他清单的比较方法为更好地定义文件的性质提供了新的方法。在2003- 2006年的考古现场活动中,在Pelou (Grandas de Salime, Asturias)所谓的“Monte Castrelo”中,在其他令人惊讶的发现中发现了罗马铭文。它最初被认为是一个人口普查表。The inscription is a list of about五十个人书面down on a slate,阿斯图里亚斯非常common in The western part of材料。尽管它很重要,但还没有收到一份专门的研究报告,因为它的官方性质已被普遍承认为省级人口普查的一部分。最近After the comments and observations made by·洛佩兹Barja on this point, who defends that a普查function is innapropriate in this case, we can approach the issue通过状况perspectives和比较非正式method with other去年,which can forge new paths for a better understanding of this document。