Optimizing horn solvers for network repair

Abstract

Automatic program repair modifies a faulty program to make it correct with respect to a specification. Previous approaches have typically been restricted to specific programming languages and a fixed set of syntactical mutation techniques — e.g., changing the conditions of if statements. We present a more general technique based on repairing sets of unsolvable Horn clauses. Working with Horn clauses enables repairing programs from many different source languages, but also introduces challenges, such as navigating the large space of possible repairs. We propose a conservative semantic repair technique that only removes incorrect behaviors and does not introduce new behaviors. Our proposed framework allows the user to request the best repairs — it constructs an optimization lattice representing the space of possible repairs, and uses a novel local search technique that exploits heuristics to avoid searching through sub-lattices with no feasible repairs. To illustrate the applicability of our approach, we apply it to problems in software-defined networking (SDN), and illustrate how it is able to help network operators fix buggy configurations by properly filtering undesired traffic. We show that interval and Boolean lattices are effective choices of optimization lattices in this domain, and we enable optimization objectives such as modifying the minimal number of switches. We have implemented a prototype repair tool, and present preliminary experimental results on several benchmarks using real topologies and realistic repair scenarios in data centers and congested networks.