Aaron Rosenfeld, Jillian Ball, Sara Rattanasithy, Christine Tsilas, Rachel Miller, Joanne Berardi, Alaina Pupulin, Carolina Carvalho, Samantha Segal, Shaul Kruger, Ravi Bajaj, David Alter
{"title":"The implementation of a value-based learning health system for preventative care in Ontario, Canada.","authors":"Aaron Rosenfeld, Jillian Ball, Sara Rattanasithy, Christine Tsilas, Rachel Miller, Joanne Berardi, Alaina Pupulin, Carolina Carvalho, Samantha Segal, Shaul Kruger, Ravi Bajaj, David Alter","doi":"","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"<p><strong>Objective: </strong>While value-based learning health systems may address challenges associated with the integrative delivery of therapeutic lifestyle management in usual care, the extent to which they have been evaluated in real-world settings have remained limited.</p><p><strong>Methods: </strong>To explore the feasibility and user-experiences, associated with the first-year implementation of a preventative Learning Health System (LHS), consecutive patients were evaluated following referral from primary and/or specialty care providers from the Halton and Greater Toronto Area in Ontario, Canada, between December 2020 and December 2021. The integration of a LHS into medical care was facilitated using a digital e-learning platform, and consisted of exercise, lifestyle, and disease-management counselling. The dynamic monitoring of user-data allowed patients and providers to modify goals, treatment plans, and care-delivery in real-time in accordance with patient engagement, weekly exercise, and risk-factor targets. All program costs were covered by the public-payer health care system using a physician fee-for-service payment model. Descriptive statistics evaluated attendance to prescheduled visits, drop-out rates, changes in self-reported weekly Metabolic Expenditure Task-Minutes (MET-MINUTES), perceived changes in health knowledge, lifestyle behaviours, health status, satisfaction with care, and programmatic costs.</p><p><strong>Results: </strong>378 of 437 patients (86.5%) enrolled in the 6-month program; The average age of patients was 61.2 ± 12.2, 156 (41.3%) of which were female and 140 (37.0%) with established coronary disease. After 1 year, 15.6% dropped out of the program. On average, weekly MET-MINUTES rose by 191.1 throughout the program (95% CI [331.82, 57.96], P=0.007), with increases most prominent among sedentary populations. Participants reported significant improvements in perceived health status and health knowledge, at a total health-care delivery cost of $517.70 per patient for a completed program.</p><p><strong>Conclusion: </strong>The implementation of an integrative preventative learning health system was feasible, with high patient engagement and favourable user-experiences. Further research is required to compare health outcomes against usual care.</p>","PeriodicalId":7427,"journal":{"name":"American journal of cardiovascular disease","volume":null,"pages":null},"PeriodicalIF":1.3000,"publicationDate":"2023-01-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10193245/pdf/ajcd0013-0087.pdf","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"American journal of cardiovascular disease","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Objective: While value-based learning health systems may address challenges associated with the integrative delivery of therapeutic lifestyle management in usual care, the extent to which they have been evaluated in real-world settings have remained limited.
Methods: To explore the feasibility and user-experiences, associated with the first-year implementation of a preventative Learning Health System (LHS), consecutive patients were evaluated following referral from primary and/or specialty care providers from the Halton and Greater Toronto Area in Ontario, Canada, between December 2020 and December 2021. The integration of a LHS into medical care was facilitated using a digital e-learning platform, and consisted of exercise, lifestyle, and disease-management counselling. The dynamic monitoring of user-data allowed patients and providers to modify goals, treatment plans, and care-delivery in real-time in accordance with patient engagement, weekly exercise, and risk-factor targets. All program costs were covered by the public-payer health care system using a physician fee-for-service payment model. Descriptive statistics evaluated attendance to prescheduled visits, drop-out rates, changes in self-reported weekly Metabolic Expenditure Task-Minutes (MET-MINUTES), perceived changes in health knowledge, lifestyle behaviours, health status, satisfaction with care, and programmatic costs.
Results: 378 of 437 patients (86.5%) enrolled in the 6-month program; The average age of patients was 61.2 ± 12.2, 156 (41.3%) of which were female and 140 (37.0%) with established coronary disease. After 1 year, 15.6% dropped out of the program. On average, weekly MET-MINUTES rose by 191.1 throughout the program (95% CI [331.82, 57.96], P=0.007), with increases most prominent among sedentary populations. Participants reported significant improvements in perceived health status and health knowledge, at a total health-care delivery cost of $517.70 per patient for a completed program.
Conclusion: The implementation of an integrative preventative learning health system was feasible, with high patient engagement and favourable user-experiences. Further research is required to compare health outcomes against usual care.
目的:虽然基于价值的学习卫生系统可以解决与常规护理中治疗性生活方式管理的综合提供相关的挑战,但它们在现实环境中的评估程度仍然有限。方法:为了探索预防性学习健康系统(LHS)第一年实施的可行性和用户体验,在2020年12月至2021年12月期间,对来自加拿大安大略省霍尔顿和大多伦多地区的初级和/或专业护理提供者转诊的连续患者进行了评估。使用数字电子学习平台促进了LHS与医疗保健的整合,该平台包括锻炼、生活方式和疾病管理咨询。用户数据的动态监测允许患者和提供者根据患者参与、每周锻炼和风险因素目标实时修改目标、治疗计划和护理交付。所有项目费用都由公共支付医疗保健系统支付,采用医生按服务收费的支付模式。描述性统计评估了预约就诊的出席率、退出率、自我报告的每周代谢消耗任务分钟(MET-MINUTES)的变化、健康知识的感知变化、生活方式行为、健康状况、护理满意度和项目成本。结果:437名患者中有378名(86.5%)参加了为期6个月的项目;患者平均年龄61.2±12.2岁,其中女性156例(41.3%),确诊冠心病140例(37.0%)。一年后,15.6%的人退出了这个项目。在整个项目中,每周MET-MINUTES平均增加了191.1分钟(95% CI [331.82, 57.96], P=0.007),其中久坐人群的增加最为显著。参与者报告说,在感知健康状况和健康知识方面有了显著改善,完成一个项目后,每位患者的医疗保健交付总成本为517.70美元。结论:综合预防学习卫生系统的实施是可行的,患者参与度高,用户体验良好。需要进一步研究将健康结果与常规护理进行比较。